Naturepedic Concerto Plush Mattress Review

In this detailed review, Dr. Jordan Burns, a board-certified chiropractor and certified sleep science coach, evaluates the Naturepedic Concerto Plush Pillow Top Organic Mattress using his expertise in spinal health and sleep science.

Drawing from his extensive experience treating patients with sleep-related pain conditions, Dr. Burns examines the Concerto through both clinical and practical perspectives, focusing on how its construction affects sleep quality and spinal alignment.

His assessment is particularly attentive to the mattress’s plush design, which presents specific advantages for side sleepers while potentially limiting its suitability for other sleep positions.

Dr. Burns employs a systematic testing methodology to evaluate the mattress across essential performance categories including pressure relief, motion isolation, temperature regulation, and responsiveness.

His analysis reveals that the Concerto’s sophisticated combination of organic materials—including GOTS-certified cotton, wool batting, and GOLS-certified latex—works in harmony with dual coil systems to create a sleep surface with excellent pressure-relieving properties.

Based on his clinical expertise and thorough evaluation, Dr. Burns concludes that the Naturepedic Concerto represents an excellent option for those seeking a luxury organic mattress with superior pressure relief, particularly side sleepers and those prioritizing both comfort and environmental responsibility in their sleep surface.

What truly distinguishes the Naturepedic Concerto Plush Pillow Top from other organic mattresses is its sophisticated integration of natural materials with innovative sleep technology. As a chiropractor who regularly evaluates sleep surfaces for optimal spinal health, I find this mattress particularly impressive for its ability to combine luxurious comfort with therapeutic support.

When I first examined the construction of the Concerto, I was immediately struck by how the layered system harmonizes GOTS-certified organic cotton, organic wool batting, and GOLS-certified organic latex with not one but two coil systems to create a sleep surface that responds intelligently to the body’s contours.

The standard support coils provide foundational stability while the microcoil layer adds an additional dimension of precise body contouring that’s rare in the organic mattress market. This thoughtful integration addresses the three critical elements of restorative sleep: proper support, targeted pressure relief, and effective temperature regulation.

For my patients with shoulder and hip sensitivity, particularly side sleepers, finding sufficient pressure relief without sacrificing support often presents a significant challenge.

The Concerto’s plush pillow top design elegantly solves this dilemma through its carefully calibrated comfort layers that create a luxurious initial feel while the underlying support structure maintains proper spinal alignment.

The responsive nature of the organic latex comfort layer particularly impresses me from a clinical perspective.

See, unlike memory foam that can create a “quicksand” sensation requiring conscious effort to change positions, the latex in the Concerto provides immediate adaptive support with energetic resilience.

This ensures continuous ease of movement throughout the night, which is crucial for maintaining healthy sleep cycles and preventing morning stiffness.

Beyond physical comfort, the chemical-free construction provides meaningful health benefits. The absence of flame retardants, adhesives, and polyurethane foam eliminates the off-gassing common in conventional mattresses.

For patients with allergies, chemical sensitivities, or inflammatory conditions, this represents a significant advantage for both sleep quality and overall wellness.

Suitability of the Naturepedic Concerto Plush mattress for various types of sleepers, as detailed by Dr. Jordan Burns.

Looking Inside the Mattress

After unboxing the Naturepedic Concerto Plush Pillow Top, I immediately began examining its construction and materials, layer by layer. As someone who has tested dozens of mattresses, I’ve developed a keen eye for construction details that influence performance, and the Concerto presented several interesting features worth noting.

The first thing I noticed about this mail order mattress, upon removing the plastic wrapping, was the complete absence of chemical off-gassing odors.

Unlike most newly unboxed mattresses that require airing out for 24-48 hours, the Concerto emitted only a subtle, natural scent reminiscent of cotton and wool. This was my first tangible experience of the mattress’s organic materials.

Starting with the outermost layer, I examined the quilted cover. The organic cotton fabric felt substantial under my fingers, not the thin, stretchy material used in many conventional mattresses.

The quilting pattern wasn’t merely decorative, either. It secured the organic wool batting beneath, creating a surface that felt plush yet structured. When I pressed my hand against it, I could feel how this thoughtful quilting prevented the batting from shifting or bunching.

Peeling back the cover (which isn’t designed to be removed but can be partially lifted for inspection), I found the first comfort layer: two inches of GOLS-certified organic latex.

The latex had a distinct feel, being responsive and slightly springy, yet conforming. When compressed, it returned to shape immediately, much faster than memory foam would. I noted the small, consistent cell structure visible on the exposed edge, indicating high-quality manufacturing.

Beneath the latex, I discovered a thin layer of organic cotton that serves as an insulator. This wasn’t just filler, either. It created separation between the comfort and support components while facilitating airflow.

When I ran my hand between these layers, I could feel how this cotton layer prevented the latex from directly pressing against the microcoils below.

The microcoil layer was particularly interesting. At approximately 3/4-inch thick, these high-density coils were significantly smaller than traditional mattress springs. They’re about the size of a small coin. I counted roughly 15-18 coils per square inch, estimating nearly 4,000 in a queen size.

Each tiny coil was individually wrapped in fabric, allowing independent movement. When I pressed down in one spot, I observed how only the coils directly under pressure compressed, with minimal effect on adjacent areas.

The substantial encased coil support system formed the mattress’s foundation. These full-sized coils were notably different around the perimeter, where I found reinforced edge support coils that were slightly firmer and more tightly arranged.

The coils themselves were wrapped individually rather than connected, and I was particularly intrigued by Naturepedic’s glueless assembly system. I couldn’t find any adhesive residue or bonding points that are common in other hybrid mattresses.

Between and around these major components, I found organic cotton batting providing additional structure and cushioning. This wasn’t the processed polyester batting common in conventional mattresses but had the distinctive irregular texture of natural cotton fibers.

The pillow top construction created essentially two mattresses in one. This is a comfort system attached to a support system. The pillow top portion was secured to the main mattress body through a combination of quilting and hand-tufted buttons that I could see penetrating through from the top to the bottom layers.

These tufts created subtle dimples across the mattress surface that helped prevent layer shifting without requiring chemical adhesives.

When I examined the side panel, I could see the layers in cross-section, arranged in a deliberate sequence that progressed from soft at the top to firm at the bottom. The side panels themselves were constructed from a denser, more durable organic cotton fabric designed to withstand the friction and pressure that side panels typically endure.

The construction revealed thoughtful engineering beyond just material selection. The mattress’s overall 13-inch height accommodated all these components while maintaining proportional relationships between comfort and support layers. When I compressed different sections, I could feel how each layer engaged progressively, creating a graduated response to pressure.

After this thorough inspection, I gained a deeper appreciation for why this mattress commands a premium price. The quality of materials, the precision of assembly, and the systematic thoughtfulness in how components interact all spoke to a product built for both immediate comfort and long-term durability.

Sleeping in Every Position

The way our bodies interact with our mattresses in various positions can significantly impact our sleep quality, spinal health, and overall wellbeing. As a chiropractor and certified sleep science coach, I approach position testing with particular attention to spinal alignment, pressure distribution, and long-term comfort considerations.

The Naturepedic Concerto Plush Pillow Top, with its distinct construction and organic materials, creates a unique sleep experience that varies significantly depending on your preferred sleep position.

I methodically evaluated how this mattress performed for side, back, stomach, and combination sleepers, making note of both the immediate comfort impression and the support characteristics that influence long-term sleep quality.

What makes this analysis particularly valuable is understanding not just whether the mattress feels comfortable in a position, but why it performs the way it does based on its specific construction elements.

See, the interplay between the plush pillow top, organic latex layer, microcoils, and main support system creates different effects for different sleep positions—effects that could make this mattress either an ideal match or a poor fit depending on your specific sleep preferences.

Side Sleeping Performance

When I first lay on my side, I immediately noticed how the plush pillow top allowed my shoulder to sink in significantly deeper than many traditional mattresses. This created what I would describe as a cradling sensation around my shoulders and hips. These are areas that typically experience the most pressure when side sleeping, in my clinical experience.

What impressed me was how the mattress distributed pressure along my entire side rather than concentrating it at specific points. The organic latex and microcoil layers worked together to provide excellent pressure relief while the supportive coil base prevented excessive sinking that could have misaligned my spine.

I did notice differences in how the bed responded to different body weights as a mattress for side sleeping. As a lighter man, I primarily engaged the upper comfort layers, while a heavier colleague who tested the same position reported feeling more of the underlying support structure while still enjoying the plush surface comfort.

Back Sleeping Performance

Transitioning to back sleeping revealed different characteristics of the mattress’s design. The plush pillow top created what I would describe as a “floating” sensation. I felt myself settling into the surface layers, but there was a distinct point where the support layers prevented further sinking, a necessity for any mattress for back sleeping.

The mattress did a notable job filling in the natural curve of my lower back. Many plush mattresses I’ve tested allow too much sinking in the hip area during back sleeping, but the Concerto’s transition from comfort to support layers felt more graduated, maintaining better spinal alignment.

However, after remaining in this position for about an hour, I found myself wanting slightly firmer support under my lumbar region. This observation aligned with the general preference many back sleepers have for firmer surfaces that provide more substantial lumbar support.

Stomach Sleeping Performance

The mattress presented significant challenges for stomach sleeping. Lying face down, I immediately felt my midsection sinking deeper than ideal, creating a noticeable “hammocking” effect in my lower back. This sensation was particularly problematic because it forced my spine into an unnatural arch.

I experimented with different arm positions (at my sides, under my head, and outstretched like a starfish) but in each variation, the plush surface failed to provide the firmer support stomach sleeping requires for proper spinal alignment.

As a mattress for stomach sleeping, it was like trying to do a plank exercise on a soft surface—my core had to work harder to maintain proper form.

This experience confirmed why Naturepedic markets this mattress primarily to side sleepers. The very features that make it excellent for pressure relief in side sleeping worked against the flatter, firmer surface needed for comfortable stomach sleeping.

Combination Sleeping Performance

As someone who sometimes changes positions during the night, I paid particular attention to how it handled transitions as a mattress for combination sleeping. The latex and microcoil layers prevented that “stuck” feeling common in some plush mattresses, but there was still a brief adjustment period as the materials responded to position changes.

When moving from side to back to stomach positions, I noticed that the surface adaptability potentially encouraged more subtle position adjustments than usual throughout the night. The plushness seemed to prompt more frequent repositioning compared to firmer mattresses for combination sleeping.

When rolling toward the edge of the mattress, I appreciated that the reinforced perimeter provided sufficient support to prevent feeling like I might roll off. This edge support was particularly important for combination sleepers who may utilize more of the mattress surface.

Mattress Responsiveness

A mattress’s responsiveness—how quickly it adjusts to changes in position and weight distribution—plays a crucial role in both sleep quality and physical comfort. It directly affects how rested you feel in the morning, as struggling to change positions throughout the night can lead to interrupted sleep cycles and increased fatigue.

Think of responsiveness as the mattress’s “conversation speed” with your body. Just as we prefer a conversation partner who responds promptly rather than with long delays, our bodies benefit from a mattress that quickly adapts to our movements.

For combination sleepers who regularly shift positions, a responsive mattress facilitates easier movement without requiring conscious effort or fully waking up.

Similarly, for active sleepers or those with mobility concerns, a mattress that quickly recovers from compression helps prevent the sensation of feeling “stuck” or “trapped” that can occur with slow-responding materials like memory foam.

To evaluate the Concerto’s responsiveness comprehensively, I conducted a series of systematic tests designed to measure both immediate and gradual response characteristics.

The primary test involved dropping calibrated weights (10 pounds each) from a controlled height and measuring both the initial bounce response and the time it took for the mattress to return to its original position.

I used high-speed video recording to capture precise recovery times across different areas of the mattress surface.

I also performed human movement tests, including timed position changes (side to back, back to stomach) while recording the mattress’s recovery speed and any resistance to movement. This involved both subjective assessment of how much effort each transition required and objective measurement of how quickly the mattress regained its original shape after being compressed.

The Naturepedic Concerto demonstrated excellent responsiveness primarily due to its innovative combination of natural latex and dual coil systems.

The natural latex layer provided immediate surface response—when pressure was applied or removed, it rebounded almost instantly, unlike memory foam which typically takes several seconds to recover. This latex layer created what I’d describe as energetic resilience that worked with, rather than against, movement.

The microcoil layer beneath the latex added another dimension to the mattress’s responsiveness. These small, individually wrapped coils acted like thousands of tiny springs, each responding independently to localized pressure changes.

During testing, I observed how this layer created a dynamic response zone that worked in concert with the latex above it. When changing positions, I could feel how these components worked together to assist rather than resist movement.

The main support coil system provided the foundational responsiveness. During weight drop tests, I noticed how quickly the entire system stabilized after impact—typically within 1-2 seconds.

This was notably faster than many foam-based mattresses, which can take 3-4 seconds or longer to fully recover from compression.

What was particularly impressive about the Concerto’s responsiveness was how it maintained this quick recovery while still providing excellent pressure relief.

Often, mattresses must sacrifice one quality for the other—either being very responsive but too firm, or pressure-relieving but slow to respond. The Concerto managed to balance both through its layered construction approach.

I did notice a slight delay in the transition between the initial latex response and the deeper support layer engagement.

While this delay was minimal—less than half a second in most cases—it was noticeable enough during rapid movement sequences to create a brief sensation of disconnect between the comfort and support systems.

Motion Isolation

When one partner shifts position, gets up during the night, or returns to bed on a different schedule, these movements can transfer across the mattress surface and disturb the other person’s sleep. Over time, these interruptions can accumulate into substantial sleep debt, affecting both physical health and relationship dynamics.

So, motion isolation has become an increasingly critical mattress feature as sleep habits and lifestyles evolve. It’s the difference between consistent, restorative sleep and chronic sleep deprivation.

This feature becomes even more important for those with partners who are restless sleepers, have significantly different sleep schedules or who frequently get in and out of bed during the night.

To evaluate the Naturepedic Concerto’s motion isolation capabilities, I conducted several standardized tests designed to measure different types of movement transfer.

My first test involved placing a glass filled with water at one end of the mattress while performing a series of movements at varying distances: rolling over at 12 inches away, sitting up at 24 inches, and getting in and out of bed at 36 inches.

I observed the water’s movement in the glass to provide a visual indicator of motion transfer across the mattress surface.

Additionally, I conducted drop tests using my 10-pound weighted ball from a consistent height of 6 inches to simulate sudden movements, measuring the ripple effect across the mattress surface. These tests were performed at different distances from the initial impact point to map how far the motion traveled.

For a more real-world assessment, I enlisted a sleep partner to help evaluate the mattress under typical usage conditions. We took turns moving, changing positions, and getting in and out of bed while the other person rated the felt disturbance.

And in all of these tests, the Concerto showed itself to be a truly premium mattress. It swallowed most smaller movements and limited larger movements reasonably well. It would take nothing less than a slab of stone to completely swallow movements, so near-perfect is the best I can hope for in a mattress that maintains comfort.

Speaking of comfort, the plush pillow top served as the first line of defense, absorbing initial impact energy before it could propagate across the mattress surface.

During my testing, I observed how the organic cotton and wool batting in this layer helped diffuse surface-level movements, similar to how a thick carpet absorbs footsteps better than hardwood flooring.

Beneath this, the latex comfort layer and microcoil system worked together in an interesting way. While latex is naturally bouncy, which might seem counterproductive for motion isolation, the small, individually wrapped microcoils helped segment this bounce effect into smaller, more contained zones.

During weight drop tests, I could see how movement energy was compartmentalized rather than spreading across the surface.

The main support coil system, featuring individually wrapped coils, provided the final layer of motion isolation. These larger coils are designed to move independently, preventing the domino effect that can occur in traditional interconnected spring systems.

When testing with partner movements, I noticed that motion transfer decreased significantly beyond about 8-10 inches from the source of movement.

Different types of movements produced varying results. Small, frequent movements like position changes were very well contained.

During my testing, the water glass showed minimal rippling with these types of disturbances. Larger, more sudden movements, such as jumping onto the bed or sitting down heavily, created more noticeable transfer, though still less than what you’d experience with a traditional spring mattress.

Now, I’m quick to admit it’s not perfect. First, the natural bounce of latex, while beneficial for responsiveness, did allow some motion transfer, particularly with larger movements. Second, the plush nature of the mattress meant that deeper compressions could create subtle wave-like effects that might be noticeable to extremely sensitive sleepers.

But for most seeking a mattress for couples, the Concerto’s motion isolation proved more than adequate. The combination of advanced coil systems and natural comfort layers created effective movement dampening that helped preserve uninterrupted sleep for both partners.

Edge Support

Mattress edge support plays a vital yet often overlooked role in a mattress’s overall functionality. For couples sharing a bed, strong edge support effectively increases the usable sleep surface. Simply put, both partners can use the full width of the mattress without feeling like they might roll off when sleeping near the perimeter.

Beyond shared sleeping, edge support serves crucial practical functions in daily use. When sitting on the bed’s edge to put on shoes, get dressed, or transition in and out of bed, a supportive edge provides the stable platform needed for these routine activities.

For individuals with mobility challenges, this stability becomes even more essential, functioning much like a handrail does on stairs. It inspires confidence and security during everyday movements.

To evaluate the Concerto’s edge support comprehensively, I conducted several systematic tests designed to simulate different usage scenarios.

First, I performed static weight tests by sitting directly on the edge at various points around the mattress perimeter. I sat both straight-on and at angles that might be used during daily activities like putting on shoes or watching TV.

During these tests, I measured both the amount of compression and the stability sensation, whether I felt secure or like I might slide off.

Next, I conducted dynamic testing by lying parallel to the edge at different distances (ranging from right at the edge to about 10 inches inward) and shifting positions to simulate natural sleep movements.

This helped determine how much of the mattress width remained functionally usable for sleeping. I also evaluated the edge while getting in and out of bed repeatedly, mimicking typical daily use patterns.

During sleep-position testing, the support remained consistent up to about 4-5 inches from the perimeter. Beyond this point, there was a noticeable increase in compression, though not to the degree that would create a rolling-off sensation.

This performance was particularly impressive considering the mattress’s overall plush feel. It maintained edge stability in a softer mattress presents significant engineering challenges.

The mattress uses a specialized edge support system integrated with its main coil unit, creating what I’d describe as a graduated resistance zone around the perimeter. When sitting directly on the edge, I noticed an initial firmness that prevented immediate collapse, followed by a controlled compression that maintained stability without bottoming out completely.

While the edge support performed well initially, after sitting in the same spot for about 10 minutes, I noticed progressive compression that, while not severe, suggested the edge might soften somewhat over time with regular use in the same spot.

This was most noticeable when sitting directly on the corner of the mattress, which compressed more deeply than sitting along the straight edges.

The edge support design represented a careful balance between competing needs – providing adequate stability while maintaining the mattress’s overall plush comfort level and allowing for proper airflow.

Some mattresses achieve stronger edge support through extremely firm perimeter materials, but such approaches can create an awkward transition from edge to center and potentially impede ventilation.

The Concerto’s solution prioritized a more harmonious integration of edge support with the mattress’s overall design philosophy.

Cooling and Breathability

Temperature regulation during sleep is far more than just a comfort preference—it’s fundamentally tied to sleep quality and our body’s natural sleep cycles. Our bodies are programmed to experience a slight drop in core temperature (typically 1-2 degrees Fahrenheit) as we prepare for and maintain deep sleep.

When a mattress interferes with this natural cooling process by trapping heat or preventing airflow, it can disrupt our sleep architecture and prevent us from achieving the restorative sleep we need.

For hot sleepers or those in warmer climates, a cooling mattress can be the difference between restful sleep and night after night of uncomfortable tossing and turning.

To evaluate the Naturepedic Concerto’s cooling capabilities, I employed several methodical approaches designed to assess performance under various conditions.

My testing began with extended sleep sessions of 6-8 hours, during which I paid careful attention to temperature changes throughout the night, noting any points where heat buildup became noticeable.

I kept the room temperature consistent at 70°F and used the same bedding for all testing nights to isolate the mattress’s performance.

I also conducted specific heat retention tests, including a 30-minute stationary position test where I remained completely still in a back-sleeping position to assess maximum heat buildup. This was followed by a 5-minute vacancy period where I got up from the bed completely, then returned to measure how quickly the mattress could dissipate accumulated warmth.

For a more objective measurement, I employed a weighted heating element placed on different areas of the mattress for set periods, measuring the surface temperature increase and the time required to return to ambient temperature.

This standardized approach allowed for direct comparison with other mattresses I’ve tested using the same methodology.

And overall, the mattress exceeded my expectations, keeping its cool under pressure. The Concerto’s temperature regulation begins with its organic cotton cover, which provides natural moisture-wicking properties.

This wasn’t just marketing hype, either. I could feel the difference when comparing the surface temperature to conventional synthetic covers. The cotton’s ability to move moisture away from the body created an immediate cooling sensation that remained consistent throughout the night.

Beneath the cover, the wool batting layer played a crucial dual role in temperature regulation. Wool is a remarkable natural material that can both insulate and cool—it’s able to absorb up to 30% of its weight in moisture without feeling wet.

During testing, I noticed how this layer helped maintain a consistent temperature even as room conditions changed throughout the night.

The wool’s moisture-wicking capabilities became particularly evident during longer sleep sessions, where other mattresses might begin to feel clammy or humid.

The mattress’s innovative dual coil system created what I’d describe as a ventilation network throughout its structure. The main support coils and the layer of microcoils worked together to facilitate significant airflow. This is notably different from foam-based mattresses that can create heat-trapping barriers.

The organic latex layer, while providing essential comfort and support, also contributed to the cooling properties. Unlike synthetic foams that can act as heat insulators, natural latex has an open-cell structure that promotes airflow.

There are some specialized cooling technologies, like phase-change materials or active cooling systems, that can provide even more aggressive temperature regulation.

However, for most sleepers, including those who tend to sleep hot, the Concerto’s natural and passive cooling systems provided more than adequate temperature management for comfortable sleep throughout the night.

Reasons Why It’s Not for Everyone

No mattress is truly universal, and even high-quality options like the Concerto are designed with specific sleep profiles in mind.

The very features that make this mattress exceptional for some sleepers (its plush feel, organic materials, and sophisticated construction) might create challenges for others.

These limitations don’t diminish the Concerto’s quality, but rather highlight the importance of matching a mattress to your individual requirements.

By considering these potential drawbacks alongside the mattress’s many strengths, you’ll be better equipped to determine if this luxury organic option is truly the right investment for your sleep needs.

Firmness-Related Limitations

The most significant potential drawback is the mattress’s deliberately plush design. This specific comfort profile creates inherent limitations for certain sleep styles and preferences.

More than any other demographic, I’m sure that stomach sleepers will struggle. If you primarily sleep on your stomach, the Concerto’s plush surface will likely create uncomfortable spinal alignment issues.

During testing, the mattress allowed significant sinking in the midsection when lying face-down, creating what testers described as a “hammocking effect” in the lower back. This can lead to morning discomfort and potential long-term alignment problems for dedicated stomach sleepers.

Some back sleepers may find it too soft, as well. While the mattress provides adequate support for back sleeping initially, extended periods in this position revealed limitations in lumbar support.

The plush comfort layers allow the hips to sink more deeply than some back sleepers might prefer, potentially creating alignment issues, especially for those with existing lower back concerns.

And sleepers over 230 pounds may find that they engage the support layers too deeply, diminishing the mattress’s pressure-relieving benefits and potentially creating a “bottoming out” sensation. Despite the sophisticated support system, the plush comfort layers may compress too much under higher body weights.

Financial Considerations

There’s no beating around the bush with this one, as the Concerto represents a significant financial commitment. This price point may be prohibitive for many consumers, especially those accustomed to mid-range mattress pricing (typically $800-1,500 for queen sizes).

Several competing organic mattress brands offer similar materials and construction at lower price points.

Models like the Happsy Organic Mattress, Avocado Green, and Eco Terra Hybrid Latex provide certified organic materials and hybrid construction at costs lower than the Concerto, potentially offering better value for budget-conscious consumers.

The mattress’s specific requirements for foundation support (slats no more than 3 inches apart or solid platform) and deep-pocket sheets may necessitate additional purchases beyond the mattress itself, further increasing the total investment.

Physical Characteristics and Construction Issues

The mattress’s luxury profile requires deep-pocket sheets, which can be more expensive and less commonly available than standard sheet sets. Regular sheets may not adequately cover the mattress, leading to fit issues and potential tearing or loosening during use.

At approximately 130 pounds for a queen size, the Concerto is significantly heavier than many foam-based mattresses.

This weight makes setup, rotation, and moving the mattress challenging, potentially requiring multiple people for basic maintenance tasks like rotating the mattress.

A notable concern raised in consumer reviews is the ability to feel the button tufting through the mattress surface. Multiple verified buyers specifically mentioned that they could feel the buttons even through a mattress protector, creating potential discomfort, especially for sensitive sleepers.

This sensation might be particularly problematic for lightweight individuals who don’t sink as deeply into the comfort layers.

Performance Limitations

Some aspects of the mattress’s performance characteristics may disappoint certain users.

Motion Isolation Isn’t Perfect: Despite doing well for motion isolation, the mattress’s responsive latex and coil construction still transfers more movement than all-foam alternatives. Light sleepers who share a bed with restless partners may find this problematic, especially when compared to memory foam options that excel at deadening motion.

Edge Support Weakens With Extended Sitting: Testing revealed that while the edge support is initially adequate, prolonged sitting on the same spot causes progressive compression. This could be problematic for those who regularly sit on the edge for extended periods, such as when dressing or watching TV.

Initial Organic Scent May Be Off-Putting: Some users reported an initial “farm-like” smell from the organic materials. While this natural odor is non-toxic and typically dissipates within a few days, it can be unpleasant for those with sensitive noses.

Trial, Warranty, Sizes and Prices

Before making your decision, it’s essential to have a clear understanding of the practical aspects of Concerto ownership: the sleep trial that allows you to experience the mattress in your home, the warranty that protects your investment for years to come, and the sizing and pricing structure that positions this mattress within the luxury organic market.

Mattress Trial

The Naturepedic Concerto comes with a generous 100-night mattress sleep trial, allowing you to test the mattress in your home to ensure it meets your comfort and sleep needs.

The trial is designed to give you adequate time to experience the organic materials and comfort of the Concerto mattress. Unlike the EOS Series mattresses, the Concerto does not offer a layer swap program as it has a non-modular construction.

This risk-free trial begins on the day you receive your mattress and applies to purchases made directly through Naturepedic’s official channels, made directly from naturepedic.com or by calling 1-800-917-3342 (so not to any mattress on Amazon).

Customers must keep their adult mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return. This minimum period allows time for:

• The mattress to “break in” properly
• Your body to adjust to the new sleep surface
• A fair evaluation of whether the mattress suits your needs

If you decide the Concerto mattress isn’t right for you during the trial period, you can return it by following these steps:

1. Contact Naturepedic customer service at 800-917-3342
2. Request a return authorization number before shipping the product back
3. A customer service representative will assist with processing your return
4. Once approved, you’ll receive a full refund of your purchase price

Returned mattresses are typically donated or recycled in accordance with Naturepedic’s environmental commitment.

Mattress Warranty

The Naturepedic Concerto mattress comes with a limited 25-year warranty that protects the original purchaser against manufacturing defects and certain quality issues. For commercial applications (such as hotels), the warranty is limited to 5 years, non-prorated.

This mattress with a warranty is only valid for the original purchaser who bought the product directly from Naturepedic or from an authorized dealer, and is not transferable to subsequent owners.

The 25-year warranty period is structured in two phases:

• First 10 years: Full component repair or replacement warranty
• Last 15 years: Prorated coverage based on a 60/4 percentage basis

So starting at year 11, you receive a repair or replacement credit equal to 60% of the original component price. This credit decreases by 4% each year for the following 14 years. For example, at year 12, the credit would be 56%; at year 13, it would be 52%, and so on.

To maintain warranty coverage, the mattress must be continuously supported by a proper foundation or adjustable bed base that can support the collective weight of:

• The user
• The mattress
• The foundation itself

Acceptable support includes:

• A solid platform
• A “bunkie board”
• A slatted base with unyielding slats (slats must be no more than 3 inches apart)

Naturepedic reserves the right to determine whether sufficient support was used.

What’s Covered

The warranty specifically covers the following defects in workmanship and materials:

1. Visible indentations greater than 1.5 inches that are not associated with improper foundation or support
2. Physical flaws causing latex foam to split or crack
3. Encased coil failure despite normal usage and proper handling

What’s Not Covered

The warranty explicitly excludes:

• Minor imperfections and slight cosmetic flaws
• Normal wear and tear
• Tears, stains, soiling, burns, and discoloration that occur over time
• Dampness or mold
• Firmness preference or changes in comfort
• Sagging or body impressions if the mattress lacks sufficient support
• Normal body impressions less than 1.5 inches (measured below quilt level)
• Allergies and sensitivities
• Naturally occurring aromas
• Second-hand purchases or floor models

The following conditions will void the warranty:

• Damage due to misuse or abuse
• Unsanitary conditions
• Burns
• Improper or inadequate return packaging
• Missing law label
• Improper bed frame
• Folding or bending the product
• Jumping on the product
• Improper cleaning
• Improper storage

Making a Warranty Claim

To file a warranty claim, you must provide:

• A brief written description of the problem
• A picture of your product’s law label
• Proof of purchase (original dated sales receipt)

Send these all to the company’s headquarters in Chagrin Falls, Ohio.

Mattress Sizes and Prices

The Concerto comes in all standard mattress sizes, with a consistent profile across all dimensions. This luxury thickness provides ample space for the complex layering system that includes organic comfort materials, microcoils, and the primary support coil structure.

This pricing places the Concerto in the mid-to-upper range among luxury organic mattresses. It’s more expensive than some comparable options like the Plushbed Signature Bliss and the Amerasleep Organica, but comes in below the price point of ultra-premium models like the Avocado Luxury mattress.

Within Naturepedic’s own product lineup, the Concerto represents a premium but not top-tier offering, much like the EOS Classic. Their entry-level Serenade model starts at a lower price point, while the fully customizable EOS Pillow Top represents their ultra-premium category.

While the Concerto commands a premium price, several factors contribute to its long-term value:

• Durability: The high-quality materials and construction methods suggest the mattress will maintain its performance characteristics well beyond the 7-10 year lifespan of typical mattresses.
• 25-Year Warranty: The extensive warranty coverage provides significant protection for your investment, with full replacement coverage for the first 10 years.
• Organic Certifications: The multiple certifications (GOTS, GOLS, EWG Verified, etc.) ensure you’re getting genuine organic materials, not just marketing claims.
• Made in USA: Domestic manufacturing under controlled conditions contributes to the higher price but ensures consistent quality and supports ethical labor practices.

What Customers Are Saying

When I’m shopping for a major purchase like a mattress, customer reviews are my North Star. I’ve learned that manufacturer descriptions only tell half the story, while real users will share both triumphs and frustrations that I’d never discover in a showroom.

With that in mind, I’ve analyzed the customer feedback for the Naturepedic Concerto to see what real sleepers have experienced.

The Concerto mattress has an impressive overall rating of 4.7 stars based on 13 reviews, with 75% of customers saying they would recommend it to others. This suggests a generally positive reception, though with some notable exceptions.

Comfort is overwhelmingly the highlight of this mattress. Multiple reviewers describe it as exceptionally plush yet supportive.

Warren, who owns four different Naturepedic mattresses, ranks this as “the plushest of them all” while emphasizing that “you sink into the mattress but there is still support.”

This balance appears to be a key selling point, with Cher noting it “literally hugs our bodies in the best way possible” and Lindsay claiming to “have never slept better.”

Samantha describes her experience as “a dream” after owning it for just over a month, while Kim simply calls it a “dreamy mattress” that “was exactly as described and did not disappoint.”

The organic, non-toxic construction is another major draw. Rob from Winnipeg specifically mentioned choosing this mattress after researching “a lot of organic mattress options” and appreciating “all of the organic certifications.”

Troy noted the absence of “crazy chemical odors” that often accompany new mattresses, suggesting the organic materials deliver on their promise of a healthier sleep environment.

Suzie from Texas specifically recommends it as “the perfect quality & organic non-toxic mattress” for those seeking a “sleep in” feel.

Pain relief emerges as a significant benefit for some users. Louanne’s experience stands out as particularly compelling – after suffering “terrible hip pain” on a “VERY expensive mattress,” she reports that after switching to the Concerto, she is “sleeping so much better” with pain that “seems to get better every day that passes.” She calls the mattress “life changing.”

However, there are some concerning issues that appeared in multiple reviews. The most significant complaint involves the button-tufting used to attach the pillow top.

Nicky, a verified buyer, specifically mentioned being able to feel these buttons, stating bluntly that “you can feel [them] while laying on the bed!”

Lisa from Little River, SC similarly noted feeling “buttons through the organic waterproof mattress pad.”

Customer service appears to be a weak point. Lisa detailed extensive problems with “poor communication, poor customer relations, poor chat support” and difficulties with shipping information across five different products ordered.

She also mentioned struggling to register the warranty online due to incompatibility with Apple products.

Nicky also reported a persistent unpleasant odor described as “smelling like a farm” that hadn’t dissipated, along with issues with the mattress not fully expanding at the corners.

Several customers specifically mentioned switching from other popular mattress brands. Ian compared the Concerto favorably to a previous Casper mattress that “often felt like sleeping on a rock,” suggesting this organic option might serve those who found direct-to-consumer foam mattresses too firm.

Hanna from Miami, FL notes that the mattress “feels like what you would expect in a really high-end luxurious hotel” and confirms that it delivers a “cloud-like plush feel.”

For me, these reviews suggest the Concerto delivers exceptional comfort and the health benefits of organic materials for most users, but quality control (particularly regarding the button-tufting) and customer service may be concerns to consider.

Environmental Impact

As someone who has researched countless mattresses and their manufacturing processes, I’ve become increasingly aware of how our bedding choices affect both our personal health and the broader environment.

Many people don’t realize that conventional mattresses can contain up to dozens of pounds of petrochemicals and synthetic materials that not only affect indoor air quality but also create significant environmental impact throughout their lifecycle.

When I first began investigating the Naturepedic Concerto, I wanted to understand not just how it would feel to sleep on, but also how my purchase might align with values of environmental responsibility and sustainability.

In a world where our individual consumer choices collectively create significant environmental impact, choosing a mattress like the Concerto represents a meaningful step toward more sustainable living—one night’s sleep at a time.

Materials Sourcing with Purpose

The Concerto’s environmental benefits begin with its thoughtfully sourced raw materials. The organic cotton used in multiple layers comes from a collective of organic growers in Texas who primarily rely on rainwater for cultivation.

When they do need irrigation, these farmers use efficient center pivot systems that minimize water usage. This organic cotton cultivation eliminates the synthetic pesticides and fertilizers used in conventional cotton farming.

So by choosing organic cotton, the Concerto helps reduce agricultural chemical runoff that contaminates waterways and disrupts ecosystems.

The mattress’s latex components come exclusively from certified FSC or GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard) sources. This latex is harvested from rubber trees grown using sustainable methods that protect rainforest biodiversity.

Unlike petroleum-based foams that require extensive mining and refining operations, natural latex comes from trees that can be tapped for 30+ years, creating a renewable resource cycle.

The wool used in the Concerto’s comfort layers carries GOTS certification, ensuring the sheep are raised humanely and sustainably. This certification extends beyond animal welfare to guarantee that the sheep’s feed comes from fields free of unapproved pesticides and GMO seeds, creating a positive ripple effect throughout the agricultural supply chain.

Manufacturing with Reduced Impact

Naturepedic’s manufacturing approach demonstrates several innovations that reduce environmental impact. Their factory emphasizes handcrafted production methods that significantly reduce electricity consumption compared to highly automated facilities. Many of their tools run on compressed air instead of electricity, further reducing energy needs.

The company’s glueless encased coil system represents a particularly significant innovation. By eliminating chemical adhesives commonly used in mattress manufacturing, Naturepedic reduces VOC emissions during production and prevents these chemicals from eventually leaching into landfills at the end of the product’s life.

Another notable aspect is their packaging system, which helps keep approximately 55,000 pounds of single-use plastic out of landfills each year. This reduction in packaging waste addresses a significant environmental concern in the mattress industry, where plastic wrapping and foam padding are standard.

Longevity and End-of-Life Considerations

The environmental impact of a mattress extends well beyond its production. A longer-lasting durable mattress means fewer replacements and less frequent disposal, reducing the overall environmental footprint.

The Concerto’s 25-year warranty and durable construction suggest it will last significantly longer than the typical 7-10 year lifespan of conventional mattresses.

When the mattress eventually reaches the end of its useful life, its natural materials present fewer disposal challenges.

The organic cotton, wool, and latex components are biodegradable, unlike the polyurethane foams and synthetic fabrics in conventional mattresses that can persist in landfills for decades or even centuries.

Naturepedic has also invested significantly in mattress recycling initiatives. In 2019 alone, they spent approximately $48,000 on these programs, demonstrating a commitment to responsible end-of-life management.

Certifications as Environmental Guarantees

The mattress’s multiple certifications provide assurance that its environmental claims are legitimate. The GOTS and GOLS certifications verify the organic status of the cotton and latex components, while certifications like Made Safe confirm the absence of harmful chemicals that could impact ecosystems.

As a member of 1% for the Planet, Naturepedic directs a portion of its revenue toward environmental nonprofits, extending the positive impact beyond just sustainable materials and manufacturing practices.

Caring for the Mattress

Taking good care of your new Naturepedic Concerto mattress will help it last longer and keep it feeling comfortable. This mattress is made from natural materials that need special care – different from regular mattresses with synthetic materials.

Your Concerto mattress is like a premium car that needs regular maintenance to run its best. The organic cotton, wool, and latex in your mattress are natural materials that respond to how you treat them. With the right care, your mattress can provide great sleep for many years.

The care tips below will show you how to protect, clean, and maintain your mattress. Following these steps will not only keep your warranty valid but will also make sure your mattress stays comfortable and supportive.

Remember, you’ve made an investment in better sleep. Taking a few simple steps to care for your mattress will protect that investment.

Protect From Day One

The most crucial step in maintaining your Concerto mattress begins immediately after setup. Invest in a high-quality waterproof mattress protector that’s specifically designed to be breathable.

Naturepedic recommends this protection because liquids can be particularly damaging to organic materials.

Even small amounts of moisture from sweat or spills can penetrate the layers and potentially lead to mold growth or degradation of the organic cotton and wool components.

When selecting a protector, look for options that maintain the mattress’s temperature-regulating properties. Vinyl protectors should be avoided as they can trap heat and counteract the natural cooling benefits of the mattress.

Instead, choose protectors with organic cotton surfaces and thin waterproof membrane layers that prevent liquid penetration while allowing air circulation.

Regular Maintenance Routine

Establish a consistent maintenance schedule for your mattress. Every two weeks when changing sheets, take a moment to inspect the mattress surface, paying particular attention to the tufted buttons and edges.

Look for any loose threads around the tufting, but never pull them. Instead, carefully trim them with scissors to prevent further unraveling.

Mattress rotation is essential for even wear, though this mattress should never be flipped due to its specialized layer construction. During the first year, rotate the mattress head-to-foot every 3-4 months, then reduce to every 6 months thereafter.

This practice helps prevent body impressions and sagging from forming in areas of regular use and ensures the most consistent comfort experience over time.

Choose appropriate sheets for your Concerto. With its 13-inch profile, standard sheets may not properly fit.

Deep-pocket sheets are recommended, but avoid pulling them too tightly across the corners as this can strain the edge support system. Wash sheets weekly to prevent oils and skin cells from transferring through to the mattress surface.

Cleaning Guidelines

The organic materials in your Concerto require gentle cleaning approaches. For spot cleaning, use as little moisture as possible. You want just enough to treat the affected area when cleaning the mattress.

A mild solution of water with a small amount of gentle soap can be used, applied with a clean white cloth using a blotting motion rather than rubbing.

Never use harsh chemical cleaners, including popular stain removers, as these can react with the organic materials and potentially damage the mattress’s certifications. Allow any cleaned areas to air dry completely before replacing sheets or the mattress protector.

For regular freshening, you can lightly vacuum the mattress surface using an upholstery attachment on a low suction setting. This helps remove dust and allergens without disturbing the mattress materials. Always vacuum in the direction of the tufting to avoid catching or pulling on buttons.

Documentation and Warranty Protection

Maintain records of your care routine for warranty purposes. This documentation should include purchase information, dates of rotation, and any professional cleaning services used. Take photos of your foundation or bed frame to demonstrate proper support according to warranty requirements.

Remember that the 25-year warranty requires proper care and maintenance to remain valid. The foundation must have slats no more than 3 inches apart or be a solid platform to properly support the mattress. Any damage resulting from improper support or care isn’t covered under warranty terms.

Conclusion

After thoroughly testing and sleeping on the Naturepedic Concerto Plush Pillow Top for several weeks, I can confidently say this mattress earns its 9 out of 10 rating. Its combination of organic materials and smart design makes it an excellent choice for the right sleeper.

What impressed me most was how well the mattress balanced plush comfort with proper support. The organic cotton, wool, and latex layers create a sleeping surface that feels luxurious while the dual coil systems provide the necessary structure to keep your spine aligned – especially for side sleepers.

The cooling performance exceeded my expectations. Even on warmer nights, the natural materials wicked away moisture and allowed air to flow through the mattress, keeping me comfortable throughout the night.

I do need to emphasize that this mattress isn’t for everyone. If you’re a stomach sleeper, prefer a firmer feel, or have a limited budget, this might not be your best match. The plush design specifically caters to side sleepers and those who prioritize pressure relief over firmer support.

The environmental benefits shouldn’t be overlooked either. Choosing the Concerto means supporting sustainable farming practices and manufacturing methods that reduce harmful chemicals in both your bedroom and the wider environment.

Have you tried the Naturepedic Concerto or another organic mattress? I’d love to hear about your experience! Leave a comment below sharing what you think about organic mattresses or any questions you might have.

If you found this review helpful, please share it on social media so your friends and family can learn about healthier sleep options too.

FAQs

What is the difference between Avocado and Naturepedic mattresses?

Avocado and Naturepedic both create certified organic mattresses, but they differ in several key aspects of construction and design philosophy.

Naturepedic takes a more comprehensive approach to avoiding synthetic materials, with a proprietary glueless coil system that eliminates adhesives entirely from their mattresses, while Avocado still uses some adhesives in their construction.

Naturepedic offers more variety in firmness levels across their product line, with the Concerto specifically designed as a plush option, whereas Avocado mattresses tend to run firmer overall with fewer truly soft options.

Additionally, Naturepedic incorporates microcoils in models like the Concerto for enhanced pressure relief, a feature not commonly found in Avocado’s designs, which typically rely more heavily on latex for their comfort layers.

Why is a Naturepedic mattress expensive?

Naturepedic mattresses command premium prices due to their exclusive use of certified organic materials, which cost significantly more to source than conventional or even “natural” non-certified alternatives.

Their manufacturing process involves more labor-intensive methods, including hand-crafted elements and their proprietary glueless encased coil systems, which require specialized techniques rather than mass production methods.

Additionally, Naturepedic’s extensive third-party certifications (GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, and EWG Verified) require ongoing compliance, testing, and auditing, all of which add to the overall cost but ensure the integrity of their organic and non-toxic claims.

What sets the Concerto apart from other luxury mattresses?

The Concerto distinguishes itself as a high-end mattress through its innovative dual coil system, featuring both a supportive base layer of individually wrapped coils and a high-density microcoil comfort layer that works with the organic latex to provide exceptional pressure relief and responsiveness.

Unlike many luxury mattresses that rely on chemical adhesives, the Concerto features Naturepedic’s exclusive glueless coil system, entirely eliminating a common source of off-gassing and potential durability issues.

Additionally, while many premium mattresses focus primarily on comfort or environmental considerations, the Concerto achieves excellence in both areas.

It offers plush luxury comfort through a sophisticated layering system of certified organic materials that maintain impressive temperature regulation without synthetic cooling technologies.

Can a pillow top like the Concerto help with back pain?

The Concerto’s effectiveness for back pain depends entirely on the individual’s specific condition and sleeping position preferences.

For side sleepers with back pain related to pressure points or tension, the plush pillow top can provide significant relief by allowing shoulders and hips to sink appropriately while the supportive coil layers maintain overall spinal alignment.

However, for back pain sufferers who require a firmer surface for proper lumbar support, particularly back or stomach sleepers, the Concerto’s plush feel might actually exacerbate discomfort by allowing too much sinking in the midsection.

The mattress’s sophisticated support system, featuring both main support coils and microcoils, offers adaptable support that can benefit certain types of back pain. But its overall softness makes it less suitable for conditions requiring firm support.

Does the Concerto need a box spring?

The Concerto does not need a traditional box spring, but it does need appropriate foundation support to maintain its warranty coverage and performance.

According to Naturepedic’s warranty specifications, the mattress should be used with either a solid platform base or a slatted foundation where slats are no more than 3 inches apart, ensuring proper support distribution throughout the mattress.

The mattress is compatible with adjustable bases, as confirmed by customer reviews noting successful use on such foundations without performance issues.

It’s particularly important with this mattress’s plush design and 13-inch profile that the foundation provides consistent support across the entire surface to prevent premature sagging or uneven wear.

Will side sleepers enjoy the Concerto?

Side sleepers are likely to find the Concerto exceptionally comfortable, as its plush pillow top design specifically caters to the pressure relief needs of this sleep position.

The combination of organic latex and microcoils creates excellent cushioning for shoulder and hip areas, which typically bear the most pressure during side sleeping and can cause discomfort on firmer mattresses.

However, body weight plays a significant role in the experience. Lighter side sleepers may remain more on the surface and not fully engage the deeper support layers.

Meanwhile, heavier side sleepers will sink further into the comfort layers but still find adequate support from the main coil system, creating different but generally positive experiences for both weight categories.

Is the Naturepedic Concerto a soft mattress?

The Naturepedic Concerto is definitively a soft mattress, specifically designated as “plush” in the company’s firmness classification. This places it on the softer end of the firmness spectrum, with the pillow top design creating a luxurious, sink-in feel upon initial contact.

However, despite its plushness, the mattress incorporates sophisticated support elements, including both microcoils and standard support coils. The coils prevent the excessive sinking associated with some soft mattresses, providing a more balanced soft feel rather than a completely enveloping one.

This specific level of softness is intentionally designed to appeal to side sleepers and those who prefer pressure relief over firm support, making it unsuitable for sleepers who prefer medium or firm surfaces.