Best Pillow Top Mattress of 2025: Review and Comparison

The Amerisleep Organica offers a responsive medium feel that delicately contours to the body in most positions. The thick wool cradles the body, while the latex foam layers and pocketed coils provide gentle support.

People love the Organica for its comfort and price, but some would prefer a white glove service as opposed to FedEx:

Jan: I absolutely love the Organica mattress. It’s comfortable with a good medium feel (not too soft). I didn’t realize how bad my 19-year-old mattress was for my aging body until I started sleeping on my Amerisleep mattress. I’ve been sleeping great.

Clarion: This is the first time we ordered one of these memory foam mattresses. It’s a fine mattress, but we didn’t find it any different than a traditional mattress and box spring. We are super-glad we didn’t go with Temperpedic, which at twice the price is likely the exact same thing. I suppose the fact that it can be shipped FedEx is handy, but our queen size was very heavy and difficult to get upstairs. The shipping also means you have to dispose of your old mattress yourself.

Mohammed: I love my Organica queen mattress. the quality to price ratio is unbelievable compared to similar products from other brands. I’ve been getting the best sleep of my life! I highly recommend this product.

The top of the Amerisleep Organica is GOTS®-certified organic cotton fabric, a material that pulls heat and sweat away from an individual for more comfortable sleep. The cotton feels soft with a slight crisp edge,  creating a surface that’s luxurious to stretch out on when you sleep.

The Organica’s pillow top mattress comfort comes from its underlying wool and latex layers. The organic wool is an inch thick and serves as the bed’s immediate cushion, promoting a cool, dry feel and serving as the bed’s flame barrier.

The first latex foam layer feels quite soft and contouring, providing the pressure relief that sleepers need, especially side sleepers. Next is the layer of firmer latex that serves as the bed’s transition, ensuring that sleepers won’t bow too far into the surface when they lie down and get comfortable.

The core of the Amerisleep Organica is a series of pocketed coils, with every coil wrapped for better motion isolation. The individual wrappings ensure that surrounding coils won’t react and carry movements across the surface.

Upon lying down, you’ll immediately notice the luxurious comfort provided by the memory foam layer and the quilted foam top. The foam gently cradles your body, reducing pressure points and creating a weightless sensation, ideal for most sleepers.

Additionally, the Reactiv™ foam layer offers a responsive and bouncy feel, providing an energizing and uplifting experience each morning. Combining comfort and support, the Zoma Boost is the perfect choice for a rejuvenating night’s sleep.

While the Zoma Boost is a relatively new mattress and has few reviews, those who have responded so far are very positive:

Michael T: My wife and I received our Zoma boost over the weekend. It provides us with a level of support and comfort our previous mattress didn’t. It is so stable that I didn’t feel when my wife climbed out of bed for work.

Shane Z: Very satisfied with the overall quality of the Zoma Boost mattress. Mattress stays cool all night and hardly notice partners movement.

Yianni P: I ordered this mattress just seeking a non fiberglass filled mattress. The first time I slept on this bed I realized how amazing this mattress truly is. It’s absolutely the best mattress on the market. If you have any doubt rest assured that you will not be disappointed.

The Zoma Boost mattress is designed with a unique combination of layers to provide the ultimate sleeping experience. Its comfort layer is made of graphite-infused memory foam that conforms to your body, offering both pressure relief and support. On top of that, a quilted foam layer adds an extra level of cushioning and cooling properties, helping you stay comfortable and relaxed throughout the night.

In the middle of the Zoma Boost mattress is a layer of Reactiv™ Foam that provides the perfect amount of bounce and responsiveness, similar to latex. This layer enhances the overall support and comfort of the mattress, ensuring you wake up feeling refreshed and revitalized every morning.

Not only is the Zoma Boost a comfortable and supportive mattress, but it’s also a safe and healthy choice for your home. All of the foams used in the Zoma Boost are CertiPUR-US® certified, meaning they are free from harmful chemicals like ozone depleters and flame retardants.

These foams are low in VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds), which eliminates odors and allows you to breathe easily while you sleep. With the Zoma Boost, you can rest assured that you’re making a smart investment in your health and well-being.

The Zoma Boost’s pocketed coils quickly adapt to your body’s movements, providing exceptional support and keeping you buoyant throughout the night. Additionally, the base foam layer of the mattress provides a strong and sturdy foundation, ensuring you enjoy many years of comfortable, restful sleep.

While the 15-inch height can seem hefty, Zoma makes lifting and changing sheets an easier task with carrying handles along the sides.

The Vaya Hybrid provides the best pillow top mattress feel with budget-friendly yet high-quality materials. The mattress balances a plush surface with a supportive core. Sleepers can gently sink into the bed without feeling like they’re uncomfortably stuck, thanks to the bed’s reactive materials.

People are overall fond of the Vaya pillow top mattress, most people surveyed reported being incredibly satisfied. Here are some of their reviews:

Lisa B: So far so good. Sleeping pretty well. Mattress is comfortable and supportive. Very good price for this mattress.

Amazon C: I replaced a $1200 plush pillow top mattress with this so I was nervous it wouldn’t match the comfort and softness I was use to. It did! If you like a soft mattress this is for you. It open nicely from the packaging. It’s easier to move than I expected.

Catherine G: Customer service was superb, as is the mattress. I bought a twin for a guest room daybed and now it’s my family’s favorite nap spot.

The surface of the Vaya Hybrid is a breathable cover fabric stretched over 2 inches of soft, heat-wicking cotton. The cotton gently cushions sensitive areas and provides a stay-cool feel throughout the night.

Next is 2 inches of Vaya Comfort Foam, a material swift to conform to the body and support sensitive areas. Vaya Comfort Foam embraces the body for complete pressure relief and adapts well to changes in position.

The support core is 8 inches of pocketed coils, every coil is wrapped to isolate motion for a couple’s comfort. These coils rest on a thick foam base to maximize the mattress’s value.

The Nolah Evolution comes in three different firmness options, each one tailored for certain sleep styles. The cooling fabrics, foams, and coils that make up the Evolution are consistent across all three firmness options, ensuring that the bed will keep sleepers pleasantly chilled on warm summer nights and when sharing the mattress with a partner.

Customers surveyed rave about the Nolah’s comfort. Here is what some had to say:

Shayam: From the first night the Nolah arrived my wife and I both noticed a huge increase in our quality of sleep. It’s more comfortable and inhibits motion transfer really well. It’s hard to get up every morning!

Phyllis: Ordering this bed was easy. I dont wake up with shoulder or neck pain like I did with my previous mattress (I am a side sleeper). I also dont feel it when my husband gets in and out of bed. Recommend it!

Caleb: Over the past 6 years I’ve tried a number of ‘mattresses in a box’. The first three have been just average, but I didn’t send any back, I relegated them into guest rooms. The Nolah is a truly comfortable mattress, which is huge.

The Nolah Evolution 15 is a thick mattress with multiple comfort layers, two transition layers, and a support system. Let’s take a look at its parts!

The surface of the mattress is a mix of organic cotton and specialty ArcticTex™ fibers, establishing a breathable fabric covering. Underneath the cover is 2 inches of HTC™-quilted foam, which is surrounded by a breathable border gusset designed to swiftly release heat.

This is followed by another cooling foam, Nolah’s AirFoamICE™. This comfort foam is engineered to provide a breathable structure, with its heat dispersion boosted by a graphite infusion. Plus, the material is swift to conform to the body and relieve pressure.

There are two supportive layers inside the Nolah Evolution 15 that serve as the bed’s transition. The first layer is a highly resilient foam for increased comfort and support, followed by the bed’s proper transition foam layer.

The support core of the Nolah Evolution 15 is pocketed coils separated into three support zones. These coils rest on an eco-friendly base of plant fibers for support.

Hybrid mattresses are known for their hefty weight, especially thick mattresses like the Nolah Evolution 15. To make it easier to shift and change the sheets, the Nolah Evolution 15 has carrying handles on the sides.

BEST: Best Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternatives

The feel of the Saatva Classic depends on the firmness you choose, with the soft option quick to provide a touch of cloudlike comfort while the firmer options still feel supportive, even with the 3-inch thick pillow top. The cotton fabric feels gentle against the skin, with supportive foam and coils ensuring comfort.

Several reviewers of the Saatva specifically mentioned pillow top comfort. Out of over 3,000 reviews, those who wanted this type of mattress loved it:

Nancy: I am actually surprised that 80% (or some # right close to that) of Saatva mattress sales are the luxury firm. I believe if more people had the opportunity to try both, they’d prefer the plush soft (inaptly named) as it is supportive, comfortable, and not overly soft / just a bit more of a cushioned pillow top. We are very happy with our mattress.

Tamra H: I have had lower back pain for years. We have had name brand pillow top mattresses and they just have not cut it. My back pain was out of control. My husband wasn’t sleeping well. This mattress changed both those things. It’s the best purchase I’ve ever made. This mattress feels like I’m sleeping on a supportive cloud. I ordered the 14.5″ luxury firm in a king. I’m very happy with the height as well.

Nancy: It’s luxurious, plush yet firm, and inviting. It feels very much like the luxury firm mattress, just with a bit more and softer padding in the pillow top. It is essentially just one step down in firmness from the luxury plush — not a huge difference but just enough to give a cozy feeling.

At the top, the Saatva Classic mattress features the brand’s exclusive luxury Euro pillow top mattress system. This pillow top mattress is made from foam that is able to provide a cushioning effect, without making you feel like you are sinking into the mattress. Organic cotton covers the surface, and this fabric is treated with a botanical compound that ensures microbes don’t settle inside the mattress.

The memory foam underneath these pillow top mattresses have active wire support to target the back area, minimizing the chances of misalignment. The density of the foam ensures durable, lasting support night after night.

The pillow top mattress layer is followed by a dual coil system, going beyond merely adequate levels of support to create a highly responsive mattress. The transition is a pocketed coil system for motion isolation and high amounts of reactivity. These coils are also zoned for added support under the back area.

This ensures you get support on top of the bed, but without causing the bed to feel hard. At the base of the Saatva Classic Mattress, a standard spring system is also used. This makes the mattress more durable and adds further support.

The mattress is also able to offer excellent edge support with its sturdy foam rails. This provides a larger surface to sleep on, making it an excellent mattress for couples too.

The Bear Elite Hybrid has a surface that’s hypersoft without unwanted sinkage, though the exact feel will vary by chosen firmness. The bed also works to deliver instant coolness upon contact with its advanced cooling materials, relying on PCM and transformative fibers for comfort.

People are overall satisfied with the Bear Elite. While most reported back positively, many did mention some concerns. Here is what some said:

Elise M: Love it! I absolutely love this mattress and the adjustable frame. It’s helping my back issues so much. I highly recommend this mattress to anyone with back pain

Daniel F: Went with Bear based off a friend’s recommendation (has Bear hybrid). The elite is not a firm mattress even though it shows firmer than other beds

Chris A: So far so good. I may need to return for a firm queen size. I ordered a full and require a little larger bed. Otherwise these beds are simply incredible. The pillows, sheets, and cover are top notch as well. They were free with my order. I’ve spent my whole life looking for hood pillows. These are it. I would say my overall rating is great

The mattress consists of five layers in total. At the top is a hand-quilted, ultra-plush top with Celliant fibers and phase change materials. These two materials work to regulate the surface’s temperature, and the Celliant fibers can even boost recovery by converting excess body heat into infrared energy.

The mattress also includes a cooling gel foam layer with a copper infusion, followed by a dynamic transition foam. The support core is pocketed coils with reinforced coils along the edges, all of which rest on a foundation of high-density foam.

The Helix Midnight Luxe offers a medium feel. This means it is neither too soft nor too hard. It is considered an ideal option for side sleepers due to the specific pressure relief system offered by the mattress.

The mattress also offers zoned lumbar support. This helps with the alignment of the sleeper’s spine. At the same time, it helps to provide a more breathable environment. This equals a cooler night’s sleep.

People who bought the Helix really enjoy the pillow top mattress for the most part, but one reviewer felt the pillow top made the mattress too tall:

Brenda O: We had been looking for the right mattress foe both of us for years. We did the Helix quiz, read the reviews, and decided in the Helix Midnight. It has been amazing! Delivery & setup was smooth. The first night we BOTH got great sleep.

Nathaniel S: I will say the Helix customer service has been great throughout the whole process. Very communicative and
I ended up giving Helix another shot, and bought the normal Helix midnight without the luxe pillow top layer (turns out that’s what I hated about the Luxe), and my partner and I love it so far!

Jeff P: Very comfortable so far, I just hope the pillow top holds up (we’ve had bad experiences with pillow tops from other brands). Love the pillows that came with the mattress too. Great bonus!

The surface of the Helix Midnight Luxe can be one of two cooling fabrics. The TENCEL™ fabric is the standard cooling option, a material made with eucalyptus fibers for natural, durable comfort.

The first comfort foam layer is copper-infused memory foam, a conductive addition that maintains cool, clean comfort. The memory foam is also high-density for greater durability, and it’s followed by a second layer of memory foam for deeper compression.

The transition foam is high-grade polyfoam, its responsiveness adding a supportive contour that cradles and buoys the body. It ensures the surface has a seamless balance of comfort and support.

The support core is pocketed coils, wrapped for motion isolation and zoned for special support under the shoulders and hips. The base is DuraDense foam, a material engineered to improve mattress longevity.

The Signature Hybrid comes in three potential firmness levels, with the construction of the mattress depending on what firmness you choose. The overall mattress thickness remains the same regardless of firmness, as does the ready comfort of the quilted surface. How cooling the surface is can also vary, as shoppers can upgrade their mattress with an advanced cooling fabric for a small fee.

While most people are happy with their Brooklyn Bedding pillow top, there was one complaint about comfort we found:

Carrie R: We love soft mattresses (we added the pillow top) and wanted the same for our guest bedroom so we could take naps. After a lot of research, we chose BB because of its quality, ratings, and price. The mattress is of excellent quality. It comes in a box and is easy to put on the bed.

Lisa L: This mattress is overall decent. I prefer a softer bed and ordered this in the softest and paid the extra to add the pillow top. It didn’t have the softeness of any other pillow top I’ve had, I wish it was better there.

Robert S: Just bought a second Brooklyn Signature Hybrid — this time for my daughter. These are great mattresses. The combination of the soft pillow top and the firmer mattress below makes for a great night’s sleep.

The top of the Signature Hybrid is a durable yet cushy quilted top. For an added charge, sleepers could have a GlacioTex™ cooling fabric cover.

The thickness of the comfort and transition layers depend on the chosen firmness. The soft and medium mattresses have a 1.5 inch-thick layer of specialty memory foam engineered to offer a latex-like bounce, followed by an inch of VariFlex™ transition foam. The firm option has a thinner layer of memory foam and a thicker layer of VariFlex™ foam.

All firmness options are supported by pocketed coils that offer responsive compression, with coils along the side forming a perimeter of edge support. The pocketed coils rest on a thin base for structural support.

The primary material used in the Avocado Green mattress is natural latex. This adds a bouncy feeling to the mattress. The mattress is both soft and supportive at the same time. Most people find that it perfectly balances firmness. This means it is not a hard mattress, but will still keep you at the top. The latex material helps to ensure proper alignment of your spine.

With thousands of reviews of the Avocado Green mattress, we managed to find hundreds talking about the pillow top, with most of them being positive:

Melinda M: This is the second Avocado bed I bought – this time with the attached pillow top which makes it that much better. Still firm, but with a little give to it that does make a difference.

Richard G: Pillow top mattress is much firmer than anticipated. Quality of exterior materials appear OK, time will tell on how it wears.

Steve K: Great mattress, got one with the attached pillow top for me and enjoyed it a lot so bought another just like it for my old grandson (13 years old) and he really likes it too. Hopefully, it will last, time will tell, so far so good. Very nice.

If you add on the optional pillow top, the Avocado Green will have five inches of buoyant, pressure-relieving Dunlop latex foam. This responsive material is quite durable, gently hugging the body without an excessive amount of sinkage.

Underneath the latex foam is the support core of zoned pocketed coils, able to adapt to the body and provide variable feels for different areas of the body.

A cover of GOTS-certified organic cotton with organic wool is wrapped around the latex foam and coils, providing cooling, lightly plush comfort. The wool also serves as a natural flame barrier, eliminating the need for fiberglass protection.

The Sparrow Hybrid comes in three different firmnesses, with the option to switch out the comfort layer if the firmness you choose isn’t the right noe for you. The king sizes of the Sparrow Hybrid also come in internal split options. So if one partner prefers a softer or firmer feel, each sleeper can tailor their side to their liking without the gap of a traditional split king mattress.

People love the Nest, here are some of the many reviews raving about the Signature Hybrid:

Richard R: Soft pillow top , comfortable bed . Got the twin size. firm option solid 8 in firmness but still super comfortable. To get the full experience . Get a bunkie board . Avoid wooden slats . Great Mattress definitely will last awhile .

Dina L: We first ordered the medium firmness, but that just wasn’t right for us. We contacted nest bedding, and within a week we had the plush topper. We have been sleeping on the new topper for about a week and so far we are loving it. Thank you Nest Bedding for being a honest company.

Nathan K: Incredibly comfortable bed. I got the medium firmness (I’m 240lbs for reference) and it stopped me from tossing and turning every night. I use a sleep tracker and have noticed I have less “awake” instances at night. Fall asleep on my back and actually wake up on my back rather than my stomach

The surface of the Sparrow Hybrid is a thermic phase cover fabric, quilted with gel memory foam for optimal coolness. Underneath is a layer of Energex™ foam for comfort, with the structure of the foam varying by chosen firmness.

The transition layer is SmartFlow Support Foam for responsive and airy comfort, limiting sinkage into the mattress. The support system features coils that have been individually wrapped for better comfort. Hundreds of coils rest on a dense foam base, increasing the mattress’s expected longevity.