Home / Mattress Guides / Dr. Jordan Burns Tested 40+ Mattresses to Find the 10 Best Mattresses for Shoulder Pain of 2026
Mattress Guides

Dr. Jordan Burns Tested 40+ Mattresses to Find the 10 Best Mattresses for Shoulder Pain of 2026

Medically reviewed by Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Dr. Jordan Burns is a chiropractor and owner of ProWellness Chiropractic in Fishers, Indiana. He is an Indiana University-Bloomington graduate, where he received his first Bachelor’s of Scie...

Read more
by CERTIFIED SLEEP COACH Comment on Dr. Jordan Burns Tested 40+ Mattresses to Find the 10 Best Mattresses for Shoulder Pain of 2026
Illustration of a shoulder joint with bones and surrounding muscle highlighted, radiating pain bolts, indicating shoulder pain or injury.

Eachnight may earn commissions for products you purchase through our links. Our articles and reviews include affiliate links and advertisements, including amerisleep advertising. Learn more

Updated

Our Top Mattress Pick of 2026: Amerisleep AS3

After hands-on testing across 40+ mattresses for this guide, we picked the Amerisleep AS3 as the best mattress for shoulder pain of 2026 because of how it cushioned the shoulder without letting the spine drop out of line. During testing, Dr. Burns found that side-lying let the shoulder settle into the plant-based Bio-Pur comfort layer while the hips stayed level with the shoulders, so the lower back held its support instead of bowing. On the six scored dimensions it is the only pick on this guide to earn a 10 for both motion transfer and cooling, so a second tester moving on the far side stayed barely noticeable and the surface felt cool to the touch on first contact. The AS3 suits side sleepers who need shoulder and hip cushioning, back sleepers who want balanced support, and couples who share body heat. Its medium feel and even support across positions are what moved it to the top of this guide.

Eachnight logo

Every mattress we recommend is tested hands-on by Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS, using our standardized product testing methodology. Each mattress is evaluated using the same criteria, including support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, responsiveness, and overall value, so every recommendation is directly comparable. Our rankings are based on firsthand testing, consistent scoring, and regular updates as products change, not on manufacturer marketing claims.

The best mattress for shoulder pain is one that lets the shoulder sink in while holding the spine level, and across 40+ beds tested hands-on, Dr. Jordan Burns rated the Amerisleep AS3 the strongest all-around choice, with nine more picks below it for specific sleepers and builds. Shoulder pressure builds fastest for side sleepers on a surface that is too firm to let the shoulder settle, so the picks here were judged on how far the shoulder sank, whether the hips stayed level, and how the surface behaved when a tester changed positions.

Shoulder pain has many causes, from a night in an awkward position to a longer-term condition, and a mattress cannot diagnose which one you have. What the right mattress can do is take pressure off the shoulder joint while keeping the spine supported, which is exactly what Dr. Burns tested for on each bed in this guide.

The list below spans memory foam, latex, innerspring, and hybrid builds so it covers side, back, and combination sleepers across body types. If your current mattress has gone soft or sags, a new one may be all that is needed to fall asleep faster and rest more comfortably. For a broader shortlist, see our guide to the best mattresses.

Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS, tested every mattress in this guide hands-on at eachnight’s facility, part of the 40+ beds our team has put through the same process. The 10 picks here were scored on the same six dimensions that carry a number in each product box: value, edge support, trial period, response time, motion transfer, and cooling and breathability. We also judged two qualitative dimensions that matter most for shoulder pain but do not carry a score, pressure relief and spinal alignment.

Each dimension was assessed the same way on every bed. Edge support was checked by sitting and lying along the perimeter to see how far it compressed. Motion transfer was checked with a second tester moving on the far side while another stayed still. Surface temperature was compared by touch through the first hours against the other beds tested in the same session, so cooling is always a comparison, never a promise. Pressure relief and spinal alignment were judged position by position, watching how far the shoulder and hip sank and whether the hips stayed level with the shoulders.

For a shoulder-pain guide, the dimensions that carried the most weight were pressure relief at the shoulder and hip and spinal alignment while side-lying. The top pick had to cushion the shoulder without letting the midsection sag. The Amerisleep AS3 earned the top spot on that basis: Dr. Burns found the shoulder settled in while the hips stayed level, and on the scored dimensions it is the only bed here to reach 10 for both motion transfer and cooling.

The highest overall score does not automatically win a category. The AS3 ties the FORM Prime at 9.5 overall, and the Nest Bedding Sparrow actually posts the third-highest overall score while sitting lower in the ranking, because each pick is placed where it fit best in testing rather than by aggregate score alone. We never adjust a score to justify a ranking. A bed can lead its category on shoulder-and-hip pressure relief even when another bed scores higher across all six dimensions.

You can trust these rankings because they come from hands-on testing rather than spec sheets, every pick is routed to the sleepers it actually fit on the bed, and every pick carries a stated limitation so you can see the trade-off before you buy. The full process is documented here: How We Test Mattresses.

1. Best Mattress Overall Amerisleep AS3

Man side sleeping on the Amerisleep AS3 mattress to evaluate shoulder and hip pressure relief.
Man back sleeping on the Amerisleep AS3 mattress to evaluate spinal support.
Person sitting on the edge of an Amerisleep AS3 mattress on a simple white base, looking downward.
Close-up of the Amerisleep AS3 mattress corner showing its white and light blue dotted cover and navy blue base panel with branded label.
Amerisleep AS3 mattress shown alone against a light pink background with a white circle behind it.
  • Price: $849 – $1798
  • Mattress Type: Memory Foam
  • Mattress Height: 12 inches
  • Firmness: Medium (5 to 6 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for side sleepers with shoulder pain seeking a mix of plushness and support
  • Available in: twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, and split king

Warranty

20 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers

  • Petite sleepers

  • Hot sleepers

  • Eco-conscious shoppers

Mattress Highlights

  • Thick comfort layer of plant-based memory foam

  • Targeted support from Affinity foam transition layer with HIVE® technology

  • Durable base of Bio-Core® foam takes on bodyweight

Save $500 Off All Mattresses on the Amerisleep AS3 with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Amerisleep AS3 Video Review

The Amerisleep AS3 tops this guide because it did the one thing a shoulder-pain mattress has to do: it let the shoulder sink in without letting the spine follow. During testing, Dr. Burns found that on the side the shoulder settled into the plant-based Bio-Pur comfort layer while the hips stayed level with it, which kept the lower back from bowing. That balance is why a medium all-foam bed beat firmer, bouncier picks for this particular need.

On the scored dimensions the AS3 is the only bed on this guide to reach 10 for both motion transfer and cooling. A second tester moving on the far side barely registered, and the surface felt cool to the touch on first contact rather than warming quickly the way the denser foam beds we compared did. It ties the FORM Prime at 9.5 overall, but where the FORM answers with a responsive grid, the AS3 answers with a slower, more cradling foam, which is the better match for a sleeper who wants the shoulder cushioned rather than pushed back.

The AS3 fits side sleepers who wake with shoulder or hip pressure, back sleepers who want support without a firm push, and couples sharing heat in a queen or king. Sleepers who prefer a firmer, springier surface, or who sleep mostly on the stomach, will want to look further down this list.

9.5 Overall Score
  • 9 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 9 Response Time
  • 10 Motion Transfer
  • 10 Cooling & Breathability

We named the AS3 the best overall for shoulder pain because it pairs shoulder cushioning with steady midsection support in a single medium feel. During testing, Dr. Burns found the zoned Affinity transition layer let the shoulder press in while the firmer foam under the hips held them up, so the spine stayed in line on the side. Motion isolation stood out: when a second tester shifted on the far side, the movement stayed barely noticeable, which helps light-sleeping couples. The surface also felt cooler to the touch through the first hours than the denser all-foam beds we compared, a real difference for two sleepers sharing heat.

Best For:

  • Side sleepers who wake with shoulder or hip pressure
  • Back sleepers who want balanced support in a medium feel
  • Couples who share body heat

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid if you want a noticeably softer, plusher surface
  • Vaya Mattress if you want a similar medium all-foam feel with a stronger value score
  • Saatva Classic if you want a responsive coil feel with a firmer option

On the side, the AS3 reads as a true medium. Dr. Burns found the shoulder sank in a couple of inches and the hip followed just enough to keep the waist supported, so the spine stayed level rather than dipping. On the back, the same surface let the hips settle while the lumbar area stayed filled in, with no hammocking. Rolling from side to back, the foam recovered at a moderate pace, quick enough to reposition but slower than a coil bed. When a second tester moved, the motion stayed on their side. The surface felt cool on first contact and did not warm as fast as the denser foam beds we compared in the same session. The AS3 lands best for side and back sleepers around average weight who want the shoulder cushioned while the spine stays supported.

The AS3 is a 12-inch all-foam build, and each layer earned its place in testing. The 3-inch Bio-Pur comfort layer is what let the shoulder settle in on the side without the slow, sunk-in feeling of denser memory foam, and it recovered quickly enough to reposition. Below it, the 2-inch Affinity transition layer uses HIVE cutouts spaced wider under the shoulders and hips for give and closer under the lumbar for push-back, which is why Dr. Burns found the spine stayed level instead of dipping at the waist. The 7-inch Bio-Core base held the surface steady with no edge sag over repeated testing. The three layers total 12 inches and read as a supportive medium.

Pros

  • Motion Transfer (10/10): when a second tester moved on the far side, the surface barely registered it
  • The zoned transition layer let the shoulder sink while the hips stayed level, keeping the spine in line on the side
  • Felt cooler to the touch through the first hours than the denser all-foam beds we compared

Cons

  • Response Time (9/10): the foam recovers a beat slower than the coil-heavy picks here, so combination sleepers who reposition often may notice more lag
  • The single medium feel means sleepers who want a noticeably softer or firmer surface have fewer options on this bed

What our experts say: “The zoned Affinity layer is the detail that matters most here. Softer foam under the shoulders and firmer foam under the hips kept the spine aligned on the side, and the thick Bio-Core base held the surface steady night after night. It suits side and back sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned without the midsection sinking.” – Dr. Colleen Ehrnstrom, Ph.D., AS3 Reviewer

Eachnight logo

Why the Amerisleep AS3 Won

Among the 10 mattresses tested for this guide, the AS3 won for pairing shoulder cushioning with a level spine in one medium feel. Dr. Burns found the shoulder settled in while the hips stayed supported, and it holds the only Motion Transfer and Cooling double-10 on the page. It is the bed we would put a side or back sleeper with shoulder pressure on first.

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Amerisleep AS3 Mattress

2. Best Purple Alternative: FORM Prime

  • Price: $2599-$3599
  • Mattress Type: Gel Grid Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 14 inches
  • Firmness: Medium-firm (6 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for side sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned while the lumbar stays firmly supported
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king

Warranty

Lifetime

Sleep Trial

365 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers whose shoulders need a softer landing zone than the rest of the mattress provides

  • Combination sleepers who shift position through the night and want a surface that keeps up

  • Couples who want one partner’s movement to stay on their own side of the bed

  • Hot sleepers who want a hybrid without giving up airflow

Mattress Highlights

  • GelGrid™ flexes precisely at the shoulder and hip contact points while staying steady everywhere else, thanks to Integra-Mesh™ reinforcement

  • ZoneCoil™ 7-Series divides support into seven zones, so the shoulder area gets more give than the lumbar area

  • AeroWeave™ cover feels cool to the touch and pairs with the open-cell grid to keep air moving through the surface

Save $400 on the FORM Prime with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our FORM Prime Video Review

The FORM Prime is a 14-inch grid hybrid, and the first thing Dr. Burns noted lying down was how precisely it responds. Press into the GelGrid and it flexes right where the weight lands, then holds firm everywhere else, without the slow give of memory foam.

For shoulder pain, the zoned coil layer is the piece that matters. The ZoneCoil 7-Series runs softer under the shoulders and firmer under the lumbar, so in testing a side sleeper’s shoulder settled into the surface while the lower back stayed supported instead of sagging out of line. On the scored dimensions the FORM Prime posts a perfect 10 for motion transfer, and when a second tester moved on the far side the grid ripple stayed barely noticeable, which the Integra-Mesh reinforcement is built to do.

It ties the AS3 at 9.5 overall, so the choice between them is feel: the FORM answers with a fast, responsive grid where the AS3 answers with a slower foam cradle. The FORM Prime fits side and combination sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned without the rest of the surface going soft, and couples woken by a partner turning over. Dedicated stomach sleepers and those who want a genuinely firm surface throughout will find the zoned shoulder give works against them.

9.5 Overall Score
  • 8 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 10 Trial Period
  • 10 Response Time
  • 10 Motion Transfer
  • 9 Cooling & Breathability

We picked the FORM Prime as the best Purple alternative because its grid surface cushions the shoulder while the zoned coils keep the lumbar supported. During testing, Dr. Burns found the shoulder pressed into the GelGrid quickly while the firmer lumbar zone pushed back, so the spine held its line on the side. The Integra-Mesh reinforcement kept the grid from rippling when a second tester moved, and edge support held firm when a tester sat on the perimeter to put on shoes, so couples get the full width of the bed.

Best For:

  • Side and combination sleepers who want a responsive grid feel
  • Couples where one partner’s movement wakes the other
  • Sleepers who want zoned lumbar support with shoulder give

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want a slower memory foam cradle instead of a grid
  • Nolah Natural 11 if you want a latex feel with organic materials
  • Saatva Classic if you want a firmer, coil-forward surface

On the side, the shoulder settles into the GelGrid noticeably faster than into a standard memory foam top, and the zoned coils keep the shoulder and hip from sinking past the point where the spine loses its line. On the back, the firmer lumbar zone is immediately apparent, with the surface under the lower back distinctly less yielding than the shoulder zone, by design. Shifting position produces almost no ripple across the rest of the surface, the Integra-Mesh reinforcement doing its job, and sitting or lying near the perimeter did not produce the roll-toward-center feeling softer grid beds can have. The surface felt breathable to the touch rather than heat-trapping. The FORM Prime fits side and combination sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned while the lower back stays firmly supported.

Top to bottom, each layer of the FORM Prime tied to a testing outcome. The AeroWeave knit cover felt cool to the touch on first contact. The GelGrid with Integra-Mesh is the layer that let the shoulder press in on its own while the mesh kept the grid from wobbling when a tester moved, which is why motion transfer scored a perfect 10. The ContourFlex transition foam smoothed the shift from grid to coils so the surface did not jump abruptly from soft to firm. The ZoneCoil 7-Series core is what kept the lumbar supported while the shoulder zone gave way, holding the spine level on the side, and the BaseFlex perimeter is why the edge held firm under a seated tester. The foams are CertiPUR-US certified, tested for content, emissions, and durability, and the fire barrier is built without fiberglass.

Pros

  • Motion Transfer (10/10): when a second tester moved on the far side, the grid ripple stayed barely noticeable
  • Zoned coils gave the shoulder more give than the lumbar in testing, a direct fit for side sleepers managing shoulder pressure
  • Edge held firm when a tester sat on the perimeter, so couples get the full surface

Cons

  • The single firmness means there is no softer or firmer version of this feel to choose from
  • The zoned shoulder give works against dedicated stomach sleepers and those who want a firm surface throughout, who may notice the shoulder zone sitting lower than the lumbar

What our experts say: “The zoned coil design is what makes this one work for shoulder pain. A softer zone under the shoulders paired with a firmer lumbar zone gave the side sleeper real cushioning exactly where it was needed, without letting the rest of the surface go soft. It fits side and combination sleepers who want that split.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the FORM Prime Mattress

3. Best Cooling Mattress Zoma Start

Cross-section view of the Zoma Start mattress showing three foam layers: top dark grey layer, blue gel-swirl memory foam, and white support base.
Man lying flat on his back on a grey Zoma Start foam mattress to test alignment and weight distribution.
Man sleeping on his side on a grey Zoma Start mattress, demonstrating spine alignment for side sleepers.
Man in professional attire sitting on the edge of a grey Zoma Start mattress to test edge support, with the Zoma shipping box in the background.
Close-up of the grey knit cover on a Zoma Start mattress featuring the bright red Zoma "Z" logo and white lettering.
Fully unboxed light grey Zoma Start mattress resting on a dark bed frame next to its cardboard shipping box.
Zoma mattress shown in side profile against a pale pink background with the eachnight logo.
  • Price: $449 to $898
  • Mattress Type: Memory Foam
  • Mattress Height: 10 inches
  • Firmness:Medium to Medium-firm (6 to 7 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for hot sleepers who snore, most sleep styles
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, and split king

Warranty

10 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Hot sleepers of most styles

  • Side, back, and combination sleepers

  • Budget shoppers and bargain hunters

Mattress Highlights

  • Conforming gel memory foam cradles the body without feeling overly soft

  • Buoyant transition layer adds latex-like responsiveness

  • Thick base foam layer promotes a durable structure for years of nightly use

Save 25% Off on the Zoma Start with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Zoma Start Video Review

The Zoma Start is our best cooling pick because it ran cooler in testing than the denser all-foam beds we compared, without giving up the shoulder cushioning a side sleeper needs. During testing, Dr. Burns found the gel memory foam let the shoulder settle in on the side while the surface felt cool to the touch on first contact and warmed more slowly than the heavier memory foam beds in the same session.

It also posts one of the two top value scores on this guide, tied with the Vaya, so it delivers that cooling and pressure relief on a 10-inch all-foam build rather than a costlier hybrid. The trade-off is response time, its lowest scored dimension: the foam recovers a beat slower than the coil picks here, so a combination sleeper who reposositions constantly may notice more lag.

The Zoma Start fits hot side and back sleepers who want cushioning without heat build-up, and shoppers who want strong value in an all-foam bed. Sleepers who want a springy, fast-recovering surface or multiple firmness options should look to the hybrids on this list.

9.2 Overall Score
  • 10 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 8 Response Time
  • 9 Motion Transfer
  • 9 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Zoma Start the best cooling pick because it held its temperature better than the denser foam beds we compared while still cushioning the shoulder. During testing, Dr. Burns found the gel memory foam comfort layer eased pressure at the shoulder on the side, and the surface felt cool on first contact rather than warming quickly. Motion stayed well contained when a second tester moved, and the value score ties for the top spot on this guide, so the cooling and pressure relief come on an affordable all-foam build.

Best For:

  • Hot side and back sleepers who want cushioning without heat build-up
  • Shoppers who want strong value in an all-foam bed
  • Combination sleepers of average weight

Compare Instead:

  • Vaya Mattress if you want the same top value score in a simpler two-layer foam build
  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want stronger motion isolation and a taller profile
  • Helix Midnight Luxe if you want a coil feel instead of all-foam

On the side, the Zoma Start reads as a medium. Dr. Burns found the gel memory foam let the shoulder and hip settle in without sinking too far, so the spine stayed supported. Moving to the back, the Reactiv transition layer added enough push-back that the hips did not sink, and repositioning was easier than on a slower memory foam bed because that layer springs back quickly. When a second tester moved, the motion stayed mostly contained. The surface felt cool to the touch on first contact and warmed more slowly than the denser foam beds we compared in the same session. The Zoma Start fits hot side and back sleepers of average weight who want cushioning that does not trap heat.

The Zoma Start is a 10-inch all-foam build. The ventilated cover and the 1-inch gel memory foam comfort layer are what let the shoulder settle in on the side while keeping the surface cool to the touch on first contact, the reason it earns the cooling pick here. Beneath it, the 1-inch Reactiv transition layer gave the surface its quick recovery, so a tester could reposition without the stuck feeling of slower memory foam. The 8-inch high-density base held the sleeper lifted with no sag over repeated testing, and it is what carries the 10-year warranty. The three layers total 10 inches and read as a supportive medium.

Pros

  • Value (10/10): ties for the top value score on this guide, delivering cooling and cushioning on an all-foam build
  • The surface felt cooler to the touch and warmed more slowly than the denser foam beds we compared
  • The Reactiv transition layer let a tester reposition quickly rather than feeling stuck in the foam

Cons

  • Response Time (8/10): the foam recovers a beat slower than the coil picks here, so combination sleepers who reposition often may notice more lag
  • Comes in a single firmness, so sleepers wanting a noticeably softer or firmer feel have fewer options on this bed

What our experts say: “The Zoma Start held its temperature better than the denser foam beds in the same session, and the gel layer still cushioned the shoulder on the side. Its balanced medium feel suits hot side and back sleepers who want cushioning without heat build-up.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Zoma Start Mattress

4. Best Value Mattress Vaya Mattress

vaya foam
Corner view of the Vaya Foam mattress showing the cover texture and brand label.
  • Price: $349 to $799
  • Mattress Type: Memory Foam
  • Mattress Height: 12 inches
  • Firmness: Medium (5 to 6 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for budget shoppers seeking an affordable, long-lasting mattress
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, and California king

Warranty

10 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Budget shoppers with shoulder pain

  • Most sleep styles

  • Hot sleepers

Mattress Highlights

  • Plush, airy mattress cover promotes comfort

  • Top layer is Vaya’s unique, lightweight foam

  • Sturdy base foam for support and structure

Save $300 Off All Mattresses on the Vaya Mattress with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Vaya Mattress Video Review

The Vaya Mattress is our best value pick because it ties for the top value score on this guide while still cushioning the shoulder on the side. During testing, Dr. Burns found the lightweight Vaya Comfort Foam eased pressure at the shoulder and hip without the slow, sunk-in feel of denser memory foam, and it recovered quickly enough to reposition.

The trade-off shows up at the edge, its lowest scored dimension: when a tester sat on the perimeter, it compressed more than the coil beds here, so it gives up some usable width. Cooling was solid rather than standout, with the surface feeling breathable but warming a little faster than the top-scoring beds. As a two-layer all-foam build it keeps things simple, which is part of how it holds that value score.

The Vaya fits value-minded side and combination sleepers of average weight who want shoulder cushioning without a hybrid’s cost, and most sleep styles thanks to its even medium feel. Sleepers who need strong edge support or a springy coil surface should look to the hybrids on this list.

8.7 Overall Score
  • 10 Value
  • 7 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 9 Response Time
  • 9 Motion Transfer
  • 8 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Vaya the best value pick because it ties for the top value score on this guide and still handled shoulder pressure well in testing. During testing, Dr. Burns found the Vaya Comfort Foam cushioned the shoulder and hip on the side while keeping the spine supported, and it recovered quickly for a foam bed. Motion stayed contained when a second tester moved. The honest limitation is edge support, which compressed more than the coil beds when a tester sat on the perimeter.

Best For:

  • Value-minded side and combination sleepers of average weight
  • Sleepers who want a simple all-foam feel
  • Most sleep styles at average weight

Compare Instead:

  • Zoma Start if you want the same top value score with stronger cooling behavior
  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want stronger edge support and motion isolation
  • Nolah Natural 11 if you want an organic latex build instead of foam

On the side, the Vaya reads as a medium. Dr. Burns found the Comfort Foam let the shoulder settle in enough to keep the spine level without sinking too far. On the back, the surface supported the hips with no hammocking, and it recovered quickly enough that repositioning did not feel like a struggle. When a second tester moved, the motion stayed mostly contained. The surface felt breathable to the touch, though it warmed a little faster than the top-cooling beds we compared. The edge gave way more than the coil beds when a tester sat on it. The Vaya fits value-minded side and combination sleepers of average weight who want shoulder cushioning in a simple foam build.

The Vaya is a 12-inch build with only two layers, which is part of why it holds its value score. The 3-inch Vaya Comfort Foam is a lighter-than-usual foam that cushioned the shoulder and hip on the side while recovering quickly, so a tester could reposition without feeling stuck. The 9-inch high-density base carried the sleeper’s weight with no sag and kept the spine supported across side, back, and stomach positions in testing. Both foams are CertiPUR-US certified, tested for content, emissions, and durability. The simple two-layer stack totals 12 inches; the trade-off of that simplicity is less reinforced edge support than a coil build.

Pros

  • Value (10/10): ties for the top value score on this guide
  • The Comfort Foam cushioned the shoulder and hip on the side while recovering quickly enough to reposition
  • Both foams are CertiPUR-US certified, tested for content, emissions, and durability

Cons

  • Edge Support (7/10): the perimeter compressed more than the coil picks here when a tester sat on it, giving up some usable width
  • Cooling and Breathability (8/10): the surface warmed a little faster than the top-scoring beds we compared

What our experts say: “The Vaya foam cushioned the shoulder on the side while keeping the spine supported, and the Comfort Foam recovered quickly enough to make position changes easy. For a two-layer foam bed at this value score, it suited a range of sleeping positions well.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Vaya Mattress

5. Best Mattress for Side Sleepers Helix Midnight Luxe

  • Price Range: $1099 to $2349
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 13.5 inches
  • Firmness: Medium (5.5 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for side sleepers seeking targeted support
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, and California king

Warranty

Lifetime

Sleep Trial

120 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers

  • Hot sleepers

  • Petite sleepers

Mattress Highlights

  • Edge support from pocketed coils

  • Gel memory foam comfort

  • One of two cooling cover fabrics

Save with Free Shipping on the Helix Midnight Luxe with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Helix Midnight Luxe Video Review

The Helix Midnight Luxe is our best side-sleeper pick because its zoned coils cushion the shoulder while holding the lumbar in line. During testing, Dr. Burns found the gel memory foam and Memory Plus comfort layers let the shoulder press in on the side while the zoned coils under the lower back pushed back, so the spine stayed aligned rather than dipping at the waist.

It also posts a perfect 10 for cooling, and with the optional GlacioTex cover the surface felt cool to the touch on first contact and did not warm as fast as the all-foam beds we compared. Edge support is a strength too: when a tester sat on the perimeter, it held firm rather than collapsing, so couples get the full width. The trade-off is value, its lowest scored dimension, since that coil-and-foam build sits at the premium end.

The Midnight Luxe fits side sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned with the lumbar supported, hot sleepers who want a coil feel, and couples who use the full surface. Dedicated stomach sleepers and those who want a firm surface throughout may find it too giving at the shoulder.

Hygiene and durability? The Helix Midnight Luxe has you covered with its high-quality, hypoallergenic materials and durable construction. It’s designed to stay fresh and supportive for years to come.

And let’s not forget the perks! Free shipping and returns make trying this mattress risk-free. Plus, with a 100-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty, you can sleep soundly, knowing your investment is protected.

Thinking of elevating your sleep experience even further? Consider adding the Helix GlacioTex Cooling Cover for an extra layer of temperature control and a luxurious feel. With the Helix Midnight Luxe, you’re not just investing in a mattress; you’re investing in better sleep and a healthier you.

9.0 Overall Score
  • 7 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 9 Response Time
  • 9 Motion Transfer
  • 10 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Midnight Luxe the best side-sleeper pick because its zoned support cushions the shoulder while keeping the lumbar supported. During testing, Dr. Burns found the shoulder pressed into the foam layers on the side while the zoned coils under the lower back held the spine in line. Edge support held firm when a tester sat on the perimeter, and the surface felt cool to the touch with the cooling cover, warming more slowly than the all-foam beds we compared. The honest limitation is value, since this build sits at the premium end.

Best For:

  • Side sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned with lumbar support
  • Hot sleepers who want a coil feel
  • Couples who use the full width of the bed

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want an all-foam feel with a stronger value score
  • FORM Prime if you want a responsive grid over zoned coils
  • Saatva Classic if you want a firmer coil option

On the side, the Midnight Luxe reads as a medium. Dr. Burns found the gel memory foam and Memory Plus layers let the shoulder sink in while the zoned coils under the lumbar kept the lower back supported, so the spine stayed level. On the back, the coils filled in the lumbar gap and the hips settled without sinking. Repositioning was easy thanks to the coil response, and when a second tester moved the motion stayed reasonably contained for a coil bed. With the cooling cover, the surface felt cool on first contact and warmed more slowly than the all-foam beds we compared. The edge held firm under a seated tester. The Midnight Luxe fits side sleepers who want the shoulder cushioned while the lumbar stays supported.

The cover comes in a breathable TENCEL knit or a thermoconductive GlacioTex cooling fabric; with the GlacioTex on, the surface felt cool to the touch on first contact, which is what earned its perfect cooling score. Below it, the gel memory foam and the Memory Plus comfort layer are what let the shoulder settle in on the side without bottoming out. A high-grade polyfoam transition layer smoothed the shift into the support core. The zoned pocketed coils are the piece that matters most for shoulder pain: reinforced through the lumbar and the perimeter, they held the lower back supported while the shoulder zone gave way, so the spine stayed aligned, and they held firm when a tester sat on the edge.

Pros

  • Edge Support (10/10): the perimeter held firm when a tester sat on it, so couples get the full width
  • The zoned coils held the lumbar while the shoulder zone gave way, keeping the spine aligned on the side
  • With the cooling cover, the surface felt cool on first contact and warmed slower than the all-foam beds we compared

Cons

  • Value (7/10): this coil-and-foam build sits at the premium end, its lowest scored dimension
  • The giving shoulder zone can feel too soft for dedicated stomach sleepers and those who want a firm surface throughout

What our experts say: “The zoned coils are what set the Midnight Luxe apart for side sleepers. They let the shoulder sink in while holding the lumbar supported, so the spine stayed aligned, and the edge held firm under a seated tester. It suits side sleepers who want that shoulder give with real lumbar support.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Helix Midnight Luxe

6. Best Innerspring Mattress Saatva Classic

Saatva Classic mattress still in its plastic shipping wrap, standing upright on a tile floor.
Dr. Jordan Burns lying on his back on the Saatva Classic mattress.
Dr. Jordan Burns lying on his side on the Saatva Classic.
Dr. Jordan Burns sitting on the edge of the Saatva Classic.
Close-up of the Saatva Classic mattress side panel showing the brand name embroidered on a wave-textured border.
Saatva Classic mattress label reading "The Environmentally Friendly Ultra-Premium Luxury Mattress," with a Made in America flag.
Angled close-up of the Saatva Classic mattress edge showing layered construction and gold rope trim detail.
Saatva Classic mattress on a bed frame in a bright room, viewed from a corner angle.
  • Price: $935- $2450
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 11.5 and 14.5 inches
  • Firmness: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm
  • Best for sleepers who want a responsive coil feel with strong support and a choice of firmness
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, split king, Split Cal King

Warranty

Lifetime

Sleep Trial

365 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Back and combination sleepers who want a responsive coil feel

  • Side sleepers who choose the Luxury Firm for shoulder cushioning

  • Sleepers who want to pick their firmness

Mattress Highlights

  • Organic cotton cover and Euro pillow top cushion the shoulder on first contact

  • Dual coil-on-coil support recovers instantly and keeps the spine level

  • Reinforced foam edge rails hold firm when you sit on the perimeter

Save $450 on the Saatva Classic with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Saatva Classic Video Review

The Saatva Classic is our best innerspring pick because its coil-on-coil build gives a responsive, supportive feel that still relieved pressure at the shoulder in testing. During testing, Dr. Burns tested the Luxury Firm and found the Euro pillow top let the shoulder settle in on the side while the dual coils held the spine level, so it read firm but not hard.

On the scored dimensions it earns a perfect 10 for trial period and response time, and the coils recovered instantly, making position changes effortless. Edge support also scored a perfect 10: when a tester sat on the perimeter, the foam rails held firm with no roll-off. The trade-off is value, its lowest scored dimension, and the coil build transmits a little more motion than an all-foam bed. It comes with a lifetime warranty and a 365-night trial.

The Saatva Classic fits back and combination sleepers who want a responsive coil feel, side sleepers who choose the Luxury Firm for shoulder cushioning, and anyone who wants to pick their firmness. Sleepers who want the deep, contouring hug of memory foam should look to the foam picks on this list.

9.2 Overall Score
  • 7 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 10 Trial Period
  • 10 Response Time
  • 9 Motion Transfer
  • 9 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Saatva Classic the best innerspring pick because it delivers a responsive coil feel that still cushioned the shoulder in testing. On the Luxury Firm, Dr. Burns found the Euro pillow top let the shoulder settle while the dual coils kept the spine level. The coils recovered instantly, so repositioning was effortless, and the reinforced foam rails held firm when a tester sat on the edge. The honest trade-offs are value and motion transfer, since the coil build costs more and passes along a little more movement than an all-foam bed.

Best For:

  • Back and combination sleepers who want a responsive coil feel
  • Side sleepers who choose the Luxury Firm for shoulder cushioning
  • Sleepers who want to pick their firmness level

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want stronger motion isolation in an all-foam feel
  • Nest Bedding Sparrow if you want a coil bed with stronger motion isolation
  • Helix Midnight Luxe if you want zoned coils tuned for side sleeping

On the Luxury Firm, the Saatva reads firm but not hard. On the side, Dr. Burns found the Euro pillow top let the shoulder settle in while the coils underneath kept the hip from sinking, so the spine stayed level. On the back, the dual coils filled in the lumbar and the hips settled without hammocking. The coil response was immediate, so shifting positions took no effort, though the coil build passed along a little more motion than an all-foam bed when a second tester moved. The surface felt breathable and did not warm quickly. Plush Soft and Firm are also available for softer or firmer needs. The Luxury Firm fits back and combination sleepers, and side sleepers who want coil support with shoulder give.

The organic cotton cover and quilted Euro pillow top are what let the shoulder settle in on first contact. Below, the Lumbar Zone quilting and a layer of individually wrapped comfort coils contoured to the body while keeping motion reasonably contained, and a layer of memory foam under them added contouring at the hips and shoulders. The dual perimeter foam rails are why the edge held firm when a tester sat on it. At the core, the hourglass steel coils gave the bed its immediate, responsive recovery and kept the spine supported with no sag over testing, and the coil-on-coil airflow is why the surface stayed breathable rather than warming quickly.

Pros

  • Response Time (10/10): the coils recovered instantly, so position changes took no effort
  • Edge Support (10/10): the foam rails held firm when a tester sat on the perimeter
  • The Euro pillow top let the shoulder settle in on the side while the coils kept the spine level

Cons

  • Motion Transfer (9/10): the coil build passed along a little more movement than the all-foam picks here when a second tester moved
  • Value (7/10): its lowest scored dimension, since the coil-on-coil build sits at the premium end

What our experts say: “On the Luxury Firm, the Saatva gave a supportive, buoyant feel from its dual coils, firm but not hard, with the Euro top letting the shoulder settle on the side while the spine stayed level. It suits back and combination sleepers who want a responsive coil surface with a choice of firmness.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Saatva Classic

7. Best Latex Mattress Nolah Natural 11

nolah natural
  • Price: $1499 to $2099
  • Mattress Type: Latex Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 11 Inches
  • Firmness: Medium (6 out on the firmness scale)
  • Best for green-minded shoppers of most styles seeking pain relief
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king

Warranty

Lifetime

Sleep Trial

120 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Eco-conscious shoppers

  • Side, back, and combo sleepers

  • Hot sleepers

Mattress Highlights

  • Natural latex foam with cooling ventilation

  • GOTS wool and cotton moves heat and moisture away

  • Recycled steel coils provide bouncy support

Save 35% Off on all mattresses with Free Shipping on the Nolah Natural 11 with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Nolah Natural Video Review

The Nolah Natural 11 is our best latex pick because its Talalay latex cushioned the shoulder with a buoyant, responsive feel rather than a slow memory foam sink. During testing, Dr. Burns found the latex comfort layer eased pressure at the shoulder on the side while the pocketed coils held the spine level, and the surface sprang back quickly, making position changes easy.

On the scored dimensions it posts a perfect 10 for response time, the fastest-recovering feel among the foam and latex picks here. Its lowest dimension is motion transfer, so a restless partner’s movement carried a little more than on the all-foam beds. It is built from GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool over Talalay latex and steel coils, which suits shoppers who want natural materials.

The Nolah Natural fits eco-minded side, back, and combination sleepers who want a responsive latex feel with shoulder cushioning. Sleepers with a latex allergy, or couples who need the strongest motion isolation, should look elsewhere on this list.

9.0 Overall Score
  • 9 Value
  • 9 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 10 Response Time
  • 8 Motion Transfer
  • 9 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Nolah Natural the best latex pick because its Talalay latex cushioned the shoulder with a springy feel rather than a slow sink. During testing, Dr. Burns found the latex eased shoulder pressure on the side while the coils kept the spine level, and it recovered the fastest of the foam and latex picks, so repositioning was effortless. It is built from GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool, which suits shoppers who want natural materials. The honest limitation is motion transfer, its lowest score, so a restless partner may be felt a little more.

Best For:

  • Eco-minded side, back, and combination sleepers
  • Sleepers who want a responsive latex feel over memory foam
  • Shoppers who want organic, certified materials

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want stronger motion isolation in an all-foam feel
  • FORM Prime if you want a responsive grid with a longer trial
  • Saatva Classic if you want a coil feel with a firmer option

On the side, the Nolah Natural reads as a medium. Dr. Burns found the Talalay latex let the shoulder settle in while the coils kept the hip from sinking, so the spine stayed level, with a buoyant feel rather than a memory foam hug. On the back, the latex and coils supported the hips with no hammocking, and the surface sprang back quickly, so repositioning took no effort. When a second tester moved, the motion carried a little more than on the all-foam picks. The organic cotton and wool surface felt cool and dry to the touch. The Nolah Natural fits eco-minded side and back sleepers who want a responsive latex feel with shoulder cushioning.

The GOTS-certified organic cotton cover and wool layer are what gave the surface its cool, dry feel on first contact, and the wool doubles as a fire barrier without added chemicals. The perforated Talalay latex comfort layer is the piece that cushioned the shoulder on the side while springing back quickly, which is why response time scored a perfect 10, and a firmer Talalay transition layer added lift so the hip did not sink. The pocketed coil core kept the spine level and supported across positions and gave the bed its buoyant feel. The build leans on latex and coils rather than memory foam, which is what makes it responsive rather than slow.

Pros

  • Response Time (10/10): the latex sprang back the fastest of the foam and latex picks here, so repositioning took no effort
  • The Talalay latex cushioned the shoulder on the side while the coils kept the spine level
  • GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool gave a cool, dry surface and a chemical-free fire barrier

Cons

  • Motion Transfer (8/10): its lowest scored dimension, so a restless partner’s movement carried a little more than on the all-foam picks
  • The latex build is not suitable for sleepers with a latex allergy

What our experts say: “The Nolah Natural read as a supportive medium, with the Talalay latex cushioning the shoulder on the side while the coils kept the spine level. Its quick recovery made position changes easy, which suits eco-minded side and combination sleepers who want a responsive latex feel.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Nolah Natural Mattress

8. Best Soft Mattress Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid

Man side sleeping on the Amerisleep AS5 mattress to evaluate shoulder and hip pressure relief.
Man back sleeping on the Amerisleep AS5 mattress to evaluate spinal support.
Man sitting on the edge of the Amerisleep AS5 mattress to evaluate edge support.
Amerisleep AS5 mattress on an adjustable base in a showroom.
Close-up of the Amerisleep AS5 corner showing the textured cover and brand label.
  • Price: $2049 – $2798
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 14 inches
  • Firmness: Soft (3 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for side sleepers seeking a soft mattress
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, and split king

Warranty

20 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers looking for a soft bed

  • Petite sleepers interested in a mattress for pressure points

  • Heavier sleepers hunting for a soft and supportive mattress

Mattress Highlights

  • Thick cushion of plant-based foam hugs the body

  • Active Flex layer keeps the body raised and comfortable

  • Pocketed coils react to movements with minimal motion transfer

Save $500 Off on the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid Video Review

The Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid is our best soft pick because it delivers a genuinely plush surface that still kept the spine supported in testing. During testing, Dr. Burns found the soft Bio-Pur comfort layer let the shoulder sink in deeply on the side, while the Active Flex layer below kept the surface from feeling dead, so a tester could still reposition without getting stuck.

On the scored dimensions it earns a perfect 10 for cooling, and the open-cell foam and coil airflow kept the surface feeling cool to the touch on first contact rather than warming quickly. Because it is a soft build, its lowest scored dimensions are value and response time. The zoned pocketed coils kept the hips from sinking too far despite the plush top, which is what stops a soft bed from sagging out of alignment.

The AS5 Hybrid fits side sleepers who want a deep, cushioned feel, lighter sleepers who need a soft surface to relieve shoulder pressure, and hot sleepers who want that softness without heat build-up. Back and stomach sleepers, and anyone who wants a firm surface, should look higher on this list.

8.8 Overall Score
  • 8 Value
  • 9 Edge Support
  • 9 Trial Period
  • 8 Response Time
  • 9 Motion Transfer
  • 10 Cooling & Breathability

We named the AS5 Hybrid the best soft pick because it is genuinely plush yet still held the spine in line in testing. During testing, Dr. Burns found the soft Bio-Pur layer let the shoulder sink in deeply on the side while the zoned coils kept the hips from dropping too far, so the spine stayed supported. The Active Flex layer kept the surface responsive enough to reposition, and it scored a perfect 10 for cooling, feeling cool on first contact. The honest limitation is that a plush feel is not right for every shoulder-pain sleeper, especially heavier back and stomach sleepers.

Best For:

  • Side sleepers who want a deep, cushioned feel
  • Lighter sleepers who need a soft surface for shoulder pressure
  • Hot sleepers who want softness without heat build-up

Compare Instead:

  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want a balanced medium instead of a soft feel
  • Helix Midnight Luxe if you want a coil feel with stronger edge support
  • Saatva Classic if you want a firmer, more responsive surface

On the side, the AS5 Hybrid reads as a true soft. Dr. Burns found the shoulder sank in deeply and the hip followed, but the zoned coils kept the hip from dropping so far that the spine lost its line. The Active Flex layer kept the plush surface from feeling dead, so a tester could still reposition. On the back, the soft top let the hips settle while the coils held the lumbar. When a second tester moved, the coils kept the motion reasonably contained. The open-cell foam felt cool on first contact and did not warm quickly. The AS5 Hybrid fits side sleepers and lighter sleepers who want a deep, cushioned feel with the spine still supported.

The AS5 Hybrid is a 14-inch build. The 3-inch soft Bio-Pur comfort layer is what let the shoulder sink in deeply on the side, and its open-cell structure is why the surface felt cool on first contact. Below it, the 2-inch Active Flex transition layer is the piece that kept the plush top from feeling dead, so a tester could reposition rather than sinking in place. The 8-inch zoned pocketed coil core, softer at the head and foot and firmer through the midsection, kept the hips from sinking too far and held the spine level despite the soft top, and it kept motion contained. A firm foam base under the coils holds the structure. The layers add up to the 14-inch profile.

Pros

  • Cooling and Breathability (10/10): the open-cell foam and coil airflow kept the surface cool to the touch on first contact
  • The soft Bio-Pur layer let the shoulder sink in deeply while the zoned coils kept the spine supported
  • Pocketed coils kept a second tester’s movement reasonably contained despite the plush feel

Cons

  • Response Time (8/10): the soft surface recovers a beat slower than the coil-forward picks here
  • A plush, deep-sink feel is not right for back and stomach sleepers or those who want a firm surface

What our experts say: “The AS5 Hybrid suits side sleepers because it conforms deeply at the hips and shoulders while the zoned coils keep the spine from dropping out of line. Lighter sleepers get that plush give without sinking too far. It is the pick for someone who wants a genuinely soft surface with support underneath.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid Mattress

9. Best Hybrid Mattress Nest Bedding Sparrow

Nest bedding Sparrow
  • Price: $1226 – $2452
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 13 inches
  • Firmness: Plush, Medium, Lux Firm
  • Best for different sleeping positions
  • Available in twin, twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, split king, Split Cal King

Warranty

Lifetime

Sleep Trial

365 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Multiple ranges of sleep preferences

  • Side and back sleepers who want a customizable firmness

Mattress Highlights

  • Energex foam

  • Individually wrapped coils

  • Quilted Gel Memory Foam

Save $500 Off on the Nest Bedding Sparrow with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Nest Bedding Sparrow Hybrid Video Review

The Nest Bedding Sparrow is our best hybrid pick because it pairs a customizable firmness with one of the strongest motion scores on this guide, a perfect 10. During testing, Dr. Burns tested all three firmness options and found that on the Medium build the Energex comfort layer let the shoulder settle in on the side while the pocketed coils held the spine level, and on the Plush build the shoulder sank in further for lighter side sleepers.

On the scored dimensions the Sparrow earns a perfect 10 for motion transfer, edge support, and trial period. When a second tester moved on the far side, the movement was hard to feel; when a tester sat on the perimeter, the reinforced coils held firm; and it backs that with a 365-night trial and lifetime warranty. The trade-off is value, its lowest scored dimension.

The Sparrow fits couples who wake each other, side and back sleepers who want to dial in their firmness, and anyone who wants a long trial to decide. Sleepers set on a single fixed feel, or the lowest price, may prefer other picks on this list.

9.3 Overall Score
  • 8 Value
  • 10 Edge Support
  • 10 Trial Period
  • 9 Response Time
  • 10 Motion Transfer
  • 9 Cooling & Breathability

We named the Sparrow the best hybrid pick because its customizable firmness and standout motion isolation fit the widest range of sleepers. During testing, Dr. Burns found the Energex layer cushioned the shoulder on the side while the coils held the spine level, and the choice of Plush, Medium, or Firm let a tester tune the shoulder give. Motion transfer earned a perfect 10, so a second tester’s movement was hard to feel, and the reinforced coils held the edge firm under a seated tester. The honest limitation is value, its lowest score.

Best For:

  • Couples where one partner’s movement wakes the other
  • Side and back sleepers who want to choose their firmness
  • Sleepers who want a long trial and lifetime warranty

Compare Instead:

  • Saatva Classic if you want a coil bed with a firmer, more responsive feel
  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want the same top-tier motion isolation in an all-foam feel
  • Helix Midnight Luxe if you want zoned coils tuned specifically for side sleeping

The feel depends on the firmness you choose. On the Medium build, Dr. Burns found the Energex layer let the shoulder settle in on the side while the coils kept the hip from sinking, so the spine stayed level; the Plush build let the shoulder sink further for lighter side sleepers, and the Firm build held the hips higher for back sleepers. The Energex foam is responsive rather than slow, so repositioning was easy. Motion isolation was the standout: when a second tester moved, it was hard to feel. The edge held firm under a seated tester. The phase-change cover and coil airflow kept the surface feeling cool to the touch rather than warming quickly. The Sparrow fits couples and side or back sleepers who want to tune their firmness.

The Sparrow is a 13-inch hybrid. The quilted phase-change cover is what kept the surface feeling cool to the touch on first contact. Below it, the 3-inch Energex temperature-responsive foam cushioned the shoulder on the side with a responsive, latex-like feel rather than a slow memory foam sink. A 1-inch SmartFlow transition layer smoothed the shift into the coils and added airflow. The 8-inch Quantum Edge pocketed coil core is the piece that mattered most: individually wrapped coils kept a second tester’s movement hard to feel, earning the perfect motion score, and the reinforced perimeter held the edge firm. A 1-inch base foam anchors the structure. The named layers total the 13-inch profile.

Pros

  • Motion Transfer (10/10): a perfect motion transfer score; a second tester’s movement was hard to feel
  • Edge Support (10/10): the reinforced coils held firm when a tester sat on the perimeter
  • Three firmness options let a tester tune the shoulder give for side or back sleeping

Cons

  • Value (8/10): its lowest scored dimension, sitting at the higher end for a hybrid
  • The heavier hybrid build makes it harder to move or rotate than an all-foam bed

What our experts say: “The Sparrow stood out for couples: a second tester’s movement was hard to feel, and the customizable firmness let each sleeper tune the shoulder give while the surface stayed unified. It suits couples and side or back sleepers who want to dial in their feel.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Nest Bedding Sparrow Mattress

10. Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers Purple RestorePlus Hybrid

  • Price: $2549 to $5098
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Mattress Height: 13 inches
  • Firmness: Medium-Soft (4 on the firmness scale)
  • Best for all sleeping positions
  • Available in twin XL, full (double), queen, king, California king, split king

Warranty

10 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers

  • Hot Sleepers

  • Couples requiring soft feel

Mattress Highlights

  • 3” GelFlex® Grid

  • Individually responsive CoolFlex™ coils

  • Advanced edge support system

Save with Free Shipping on the Purple RestorePlus Hybrid with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Watch Our Purple Restore Plus Hybrid Video Review

The Purple RestorePlus Hybrid is our best combination-sleeper pick because its GelFlex Grid flexes under the shoulder while staying firm everywhere else, so a sleeper who changes positions gets cushioning and support at once. During testing, Dr. Burns found the grid collapsed right under the shoulder on the side, then held firm under the hips, and stayed responsive when a tester rolled from side to back.

On the scored dimensions it earns a perfect 10 for response time, the grid recovering instantly with no lag, which is exactly what a combination sleeper wants. Its lowest scored dimension is value. The surface felt breathable to the touch and did not warm as fast as the denser foam beds we compared, thanks to the open channels in the grid.

The RestorePlus fits combination sleepers who change positions through the night, side sleepers who want shoulder give with a supportive core, and sleepers who run warm. Those who dislike the distinctive grid feel, or who want a plush memory foam hug, should look to the foam picks on this list.

We named the RestorePlus the best combination pick because its GelFlex Grid cushions the shoulder while staying firm under the hips, so it works across positions. During testing, Dr. Burns found the grid collapsed under the shoulder on the side, then held firm under the hips on the back, and recovered instantly when a tester repositioned, earning a perfect response score. The open grid channels kept the surface feeling cool to the touch. The honest limitation is value, its lowest scored dimension, and the grid feel is distinctive, so it is worth testing during the trial.

Best For:

  • Combination sleepers who change positions through the night
  • Side sleepers who want shoulder give with a supportive core
  • Sleepers who run warm

Compare Instead:

  • FORM Prime if you want a grid feel with a longer trial and lifetime warranty
  • Amerisleep AS3 if you want a memory foam cradle instead of a grid
  • Nolah Natural 11 if you want a responsive latex feel with organic materials

On the side, the RestorePlus reads as a medium soft where the shoulder meets the grid and firmer under the hips, because the GelFlex Grid collapses only where the weight concentrates. Dr. Burns found the shoulder pressed into the grid while the hip stayed supported, so the spine held its line. On the back, the grid firmed up under the hips with no sinking. Repositioning was effortless, the grid springing back instantly with no lag, which suits combination sleepers. When a second tester moved, the coils kept the motion reasonably contained. The open grid channels kept the surface feeling cool to the touch. The RestorePlus fits combination and side sleepers who want the grid’s split of shoulder give and hip support.

The RestorePlus is a 13-inch hybrid built around Purple’s GelFlex Grid. The grid is the piece that defines the feel: it collapses under concentrated pressure like the shoulder while staying firm elsewhere, which is why the shoulder settled in on the side while the hips stayed supported, and its open channels are what kept the surface feeling cool to the touch rather than warming quickly. A transition foam layer smooths the shift into the support core, and the pocketed coil base is what held the spine level, kept motion reasonably contained, and gave the bed its instant, lag-free recovery. The stack totals the 13-inch profile and reads as a medium soft with a firmer response under the hips.

Pros

  • Response Time (10/10): the GelFlex Grid recovered instantly with no lag, ideal for repositioning
  • The grid collapsed under the shoulder on the side while staying firm under the hips, keeping the spine level
  • The open grid channels kept the surface feeling cool to the touch and slower to warm than the denser foam beds we compared

Cons

  • Value (7/10): its lowest scored dimension, sitting at the higher end for its build
  • The distinctive grid feel is not for everyone; sleepers who want a plush memory foam hug may not like it

What our experts say: “The GelFlex Grid is what makes the RestorePlus work for combination sleepers. It collapses under the shoulder on the side while holding firm under the hips, then springs back instantly when you reposition, so the spine stays level across positions. It suits combination and side sleepers who want that split of give and support.” – Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS

Eachnight logo

Read Our Full Review of the Purple Restore Plus Hybrid Mattress

The Mattresses We Have Tested

Every mattress below was tested hands-on and on camera by Dr. Jordan Burns, DC, MS, our lead tester. Each row links to its written review and filmed test, so you can check our work. For how we score every mattress, see How We Test Mattresses.

See the full list, with review and video links
MattressReview and video
Amerisleep AS2Review · Video
Amerisleep AS3Review · Video
Amerisleep AS3 HybridReview · Video
Amerisleep AS5Review · Video
Amerisleep AS5 HybridReview · Video
Amerisleep AS6 Black SeriesReview · Video
Amerisleep OrganicaReview · Video
Amerisleep Organica PlushReview · Video
Avocado GreenReview · Video
Bear Star HybridReview · Video
Birch NaturalReview · Video
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe HybridReview · Video
Casper Dream HybridReview · Video
FORM CoreReview · Video
FORM Core HybridReview · Video
FORM PrimeReview · Video
FORM Prime XReview · Video
GhostBed LuxeReview · Video
Glacier Apex HybridReview · Video
Glacier Original HybridReview · Video
Glacier Summit HybridReview · Video
Helix Midnight LuxeReview · Video
Leesa OriginalReview · Video
Leesa Sapira Chill HybridReview · Video
Leesa Sapira HybridReview · Video
Naturepedic Concerto PlushReview · Video
Naturepedic EOS Classic OrganicReview · Video
Nest Bedding OwlReview · Video
Nest Bedding Sparrow Signature HybridReview · Video
Nolah Evolution 15Review · Video
Nolah Natural 11Review · Video
PlushBeds Botanical BlissReview · Video
PlushBeds Signature BlissReview · Video
Purple RestorePlus HybridReview · Video
Saatva ClassicReview · Video
Saatva RXReview · Video
Vaya HybridReview · Video
Vaya MattressReview · Video
Zoma BoostReview · Video
Zoma HybridReview · Video
Zoma StartReview · Video

Causes of Shoulder Pain

According to the Mayo Clinic, you may experience shoulder pain from any of the following:

  • A broken arm or collarbone
  • Heart attack
  • Dislocated shoulder
  • Frozen shoulder or adhesive capsulitis. This is a condition where your shoulder joint grows stiff and painful.
  • Osteoarthritis. This is when the cartilage cushioning your joints breaks down.
  • Rheumatoid arthritis, which causes swelling and stiffness in joints.
  • Bursitis. This is when a fluid-filled sack between your bones and muscles swells and causes joint pain.
  • An injury to your rotator cuff. The rotator cuff is the muscles and tendons surrounding your shoulder joint. This injury usually manifests as a dull ache that worsens when you move your arm away from your body.

Shoulder and neck pain are closely related, and sometimes you might experience shoulder pain because of an issue with your neck or vice versa. Douglas Krebs, DC, FACO of Chicago Spine and Sports noted that a recent study found up to 47.6% of shoulder pain was actually a neck issue. One example is cervical radiculopathy, where a pinched nerve root in the neck can manifest as shoulder pain.

While shoulder pain is often temporary and the result of an injury, it is also possible to develop chronic shoulder pain. Shoulder pain is considered chronic if it persists for more than six months, and potential causes include rotator cuff disorders, a frozen shoulder, or arthritis.

Pregnant women may also experience shoulder pain, along with lower and upper back pain. While it may just be a consequence of side sleeping, stomach issues, or unbalanced weight in the abdomen, shoulder pain can also be a symptom of ectopic pregnancy and may require immediate medical attention.

SEE ALSO: Best Mattresses for Pregnancy

Sleeping Positions for Shoulder Pain

Your sleeping position can determine whether or not you wake up with sore shoulders. If too much pressure builds up in your shoulder or nearby areas such as your back or neck, you may feel in poor condition when you wake up.

Every sleep position also has a suitable firmness level. Lying on a too-firm or too-soft mattress can keep you from experiencing the perfect night’s sleep.

SEE ALSO: Best Mattress for Tall People

Side Sleepers

Best-Mattress-for-Shoulder-Pain

Side sleeping is arguably the healthiest sleeping position. It promotes a healthy heart and may reduce your risk of developing a neurodegenerative disease. The position also reduces symptoms of snoring, sleep apnea, and acid reflux.

However, the position does increase the risk of shoulder and hip pain. If these heavier parts of the body are not allowed room to sink in, side sleepers may experience morning pain. A mattress for side sleeping should have a medium to soft feel for pressure relief.

Back Sleepers

Sleeping on your back can be a good position for shoulder pain. When you lie on your back, your posture is similar to what it is when you stand up straight. This promotes healthy spine alignment and evenly distributes weight across your body.

A mattress for back sleeping should feel firm and keep the spine aligned yet be conforming enough to meet the back’s curves. A medium-firm mattress is the right firmness for most back sleepers. Some may prefer a firm mattress or a medium bed with targeted back support.

If you have just had shoulder surgery, you may even need to sleep at an incline on your back. Sleeping after a shoulder surgery in a reclined position can minimize tension on the shoulder joint and its surrounding tissue.

Stomach Sleepers

While lying on your stomach may take pressure off your shoulder, we cannot recommend this position. Stomach sleepers often experience chronic back pain and neck pain from their position. Since stomach sleeping affects your spine alignment, you might even worsen shoulder pain.

When you lie on your stomach, gravity pushes your lower body into the mattress. This drags your spine out of neutral alignment. Stomach sleepers also have to twist their neck to the side for easier breathing. The unnatural angle leaves them with neck pain in the morning.

If you are a stomach sleeper who cannot fall asleep any other way, try a firm mattress to prevent sinkage.

Learn more about better sleep

Sign up for sleep health education, expert tips, and the latest and greatest mattress sales.

See Privacy Policy

Firmness Levels and Body Weight

Your sleeping position is not the only important factor when it comes to finding your firmness. Petite and heavy individuals need to consider their body weight when they shop, too. Mattresses often feel different when you weigh more or less than the average person.

A lightweight person under 130 pounds should look for a softer mattress. When a petite sleeper lies down on a firmer mattress, it does not soften as it would for a person of average weight. If the mattress cannot soften enough to conform to their body, pressure on the body can turn into pain.

Heavy people usually benefit from sleeping on a firmer mattress. Firm mattresses are often better than soft beds at maintaining neutral spine alignment and enduring pressure. A soft mattress can be considered if it has added support features, like a responsive transition layer or targeted back support.

Best and Worst Mattress Types for Shoulder Pain

Many mattresses fall into one of four categories. There are memory foam, latex, innerspring, and hybrid mattresses.

There are other less common types, such as futons and waterbeds. However, we will focus on the four types you will likely consider when shopping for a mattress.

Memory Foam

Memory foam mattresses are a common recommendation for sleepers managing pressure. The material reacts to heat and pressure, so when you lie down it molds to you for contouring support and pressure relief.

Traditional memory foam mattresses often retain more body heat, which can leave some sleepers feeling warm. Many companies now add gel or open-cell structures to move heat away from the surface.

You can find memory foam mattresses at almost any price point, and in all firmnesses. With a little research, you can find one for nearly any sleep style.

Latex

Latex is another popular material for pressure relief. This springy material contours to the body for support, though not quite as closely as memory foam. Latex mattresses can feel firm, which is why many companies offer an optional pillow top.

A natural latex mattress is one of the more durable beds on the market, with some lasting more than 15 years. Natural latex is also a good choice if you are shopping for an organic bed. Certified organic latex mattresses are held to rigorous standards for their materials and emissions, so you know what the bed is made of and how it is made, alongside its durability.

Innerspring

Traditional innerspring mattresses have been around for decades, and many sleepers still prefer them. The design leaves room for air to circulate, which is why innerspring beds tend to sleep cooler, and many are available at lower price points.

However, we cannot generally recommend an innerspring mattress on its own for shoulder pain sufferers. A basic innerspring does not distribute body weight as evenly as other types of mattresses, which can let pressure points build. If you want a bouncy bed with better contouring, a hybrid is usually the better choice.

Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses are a fusion of innerspring and foam. On a hybrid, you get the contouring of foam with the bounce of coils. A true hybrid has a coil support core with at least 2 to 3 inches of foam on top.

Some hybrids use zoned support for a firmer feel under the back and a softer feel under the shoulders and other sensitive areas. Because they combine several quality materials, hybrids often sit at a higher price point. If you are hunting for a quality mattress under $1000, you may have better luck with a memory foam bed.

Saving on New Mattresses

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best mattress for shoulder pain?

In our hands-on testing of 40+ mattresses, Dr. Jordan Burns rated the Amerisleep AS3 the best mattress for shoulder pain overall, because it let the shoulder settle in on the side while keeping the spine supported. Side sleepers who want a softer feel may prefer the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid, and value-minded shoppers may prefer the Vaya Mattress, which tied for the top value score in our testing. The right pick depends on your sleep position and body weight, so use the guide above to match a bed to how you sleep.

Can a mattress hurt your shoulder?

A mattress can hurt your shoulder if you are a side sleeper lying on the wrong firmness. Side sleepers need a mattress soft enough to let the shoulder and hip sink in. When the mattress is too firm, pressure builds at the shoulder, which can lead to pain.

How should you sleep if your shoulder hurts?

Try to avoid sleeping on a sore shoulder. Switch sides or sleep on your back, and consider sleeping with a firm body pillow so that you do not roll over. If the pain is distracting, you might want to take an over-the-counter pain medication. Stay active during the day and stick to your normal sleep schedule for a quicker recovery.

How can I relieve my shoulder pain?

If you have a sore shoulder, you can treat it at home with a cold compress or a heating pad. An ice pack can be applied to your shoulder for 20 minutes, up to five times a day. You can also try a cold compression bandage or a shoulder wrap that is snug without being too tight.

Shoulder stretches can keep your shoulders limber. Stretching may also help relieve shoulder pain. However, you should stop immediately if your shoulder pain only worsens.

How do I know if my shoulder pain is serious?

Minor shoulder injuries can usually be treated at home with rest and ice. If you can move your arm normally, it is probably nothing serious. However, you should see a doctor immediately if you experience any of the following:

  • Intense pain
  • Sudden swelling in your shoulder
  • A weak or numb feeling in your hand or arm
  • An inability to use your shoulder
  • A deformed shoulder joint

Where do I put my arms when sleeping on my side?

You might want to try stretching out your arms as if you are reaching for something. This is known as the yearner position. You may need a full size or larger mattress to feel comfortable sleeping this way. You can also try hugging a pillow as you drift off to sleep.

What do I do with my old mattress?

When you set up your new mattress, you might struggle with what to do with your old bed. After all, it is not as simple as throwing it out with the rest of your garbage.

If your old mattress is still in good condition, you might use it as a guest room mattress or donate it to a local charity. However, if it is no longer fit for sleeping, you can try recycling it through a local program. If neither option is suitable, search for junk removal services in your area.

Conclusion

Shoulder pain can make it harder to sleep at night, whether it is temporary or chronic. Finding the best mattress can make it easier to get a full night’s rest, and checking mattress warranties can give you peace of mind knowing you are protected against defects. Across 40+ beds tested hands-on, Dr. Jordan Burns rated the Amerisleep AS3 the strongest all-around choice for shoulder pain, with nine more picks above for specific sleepers and builds.

Dr. Jordan Burns testing a mattress at eachnight's facility

Dr. Burns tests each mattress at eachnight’s facility to make sure the recommendations are based on real, hands-on evaluations.

About the author
Rosie Osmun CERTIFIED SLEEP COACH

Rosie Osmun, a Certified Sleep Science Coach, holds a degree in Political Science and Government from the Arizona State University College of Liberal Arts and Sciences. Her academic accomplishments lay a solid foundation for her role in the health and wellness industry. Her certification as a Sleep Science Coach further underscores her proficiency in the field of sleep and wellness.

With over 13 years of hands-on experience in the beauty, health, sleep, and wellness industries, Rosie has cultivated a deep understanding of the science of sleep and its impact on overall health and wellbeing. Her dedication to helping others improve their sleep quality is evident in her practical, evidence-based advice and tips.

Her contributions to various publications, including Forbes, Bustle, and Healthline, as well as her regular contributions to Amerisleep’s blog, demonstrate her standing in her field. These platforms, recognizing her proficiency, rely on her to provide accurate and relevant information to their readers.

Find more articles by Rosie

Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *