Best Casper Mattress Alternatives

The Casper Mattress lineup features some fantastic mattresses that offer cooling technologies and comfortable support galore. However, some Casper Mattresses may be out of many shoppers’ price range, and others may be looking for features that Casper doesn’t offer. That’s why we’ve compiled the following list of excellent Casper alternatives.

If you’re looking for a versatile mattress that could replace any one of the Casper mattresses—from the Casper Original to the Casper Wave Hybrid—and still come out on top, the Amerisleep AS3 might be for you.

This highly versatile mattress offers feel-good comfort to just about everyone. That’s why it’s one of the best Casper mattress alternatives for just about everyone!

SEE ALSO: Amerisleep Mattress Review

If you’re looking for an alternative to the Casper Wave Hybrid that’s geared towards active lifestyles, the Zoma Hybrid may be for you. This medium-firm mattress can help you recover from your active day and wake up ready for another one.

SEE ALSO: Zoma Mattress Review

Those looking for a more affordable alternative to the Casper Original should consider the Vaya Mattress. The Vaya Mattress also offers a softer and more cradling alternative to Casper’s value mattress: the Element Mattress.

SEE ALSO: Most Durable Mattresses

The Evolution 15 by Nolah is one of the best alternatives to the Casper Original Hybrid. It sports multiple memory foam layers and pocketed coils for cradling and bounce. The Evolution also boasts a breathable border gusset to dissipate hot air even faster!

SEE ALSO: Nolah Mattress Review

Those looking for a softer alternative to the Casper Nova Hybrid should consider the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid. This hybrid is one of the softest hybrid mattresses on the market. Yet it’s still surprisingly supportive for a bed at this firmness level.

SEE ALSO: Softest Mattress in a Box

Read Our Full Review of the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid Mattress

Those looking for cooling Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress or the Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress alternatives should consider the GhostBed Flex. This ultra-cool mattress is one of the best hybrid mattresses for hot sleepers looking for the ultimate chill.

SEE ALSO: Best Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternatives

If you cannot give up the bounce and coolness of an innerspring mattress, the Saatva Classic is one of the best innerspring Casper Mattress alternatives. This innerspring hybrid retains the responsiveness and coolness of innerspring beds while simultaneously fixing a lot of their biggest problems.

SEE ALSO: Mattress Sizes and Dimensions

Another great alternative to the Casper Nova Hybrid and the Casper Wave Hybrid mattresses is the Purple Hybrid Premier 4. This is a softer alternative to these hybrid mattresses. So it’s perfect for those who need extra pressure relief.

SEE ALSO: Best Purple Mattress Alternatives  

If you’re looking for an even more adaptable alternative to the Casper Orginal Hybrid, the Tuft and Needle Hybrid Mattress may be the right fit for you. This mattress features T&N Adaptive foam technology to offer the best pressure relief and cradling on the market.

SEE ALSO: Tuft & Needle Mattress Reviews

How To Choose The Right Casper Mattress Alternative

There are many reasons that sleepers might want an alternative to popular Casper mattresses, from budget restrictions to concerns about fiberglass in Casper mattresses. And picking the right alternative to the Casper Mattress lineup doesn’t have to be confusing or difficult. You just need to keep a few factors in mind when you’re shopping: namely, your sleep style and your body type.

Firmness Level

How firm or soft your mattress feels determines a lot of things. It determines how much support and cushioning you get. It also can have a huge impact on how well you sleep at night.

Firmness level is measured on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest. However, pretty much everyone on Earth needs a mattress that falls somewhere between a 3 and an 8 on the firmness scale, so you won’t find many firmer or softer options out there.

Sleep Position

Your sleep position is the single most important factor in determining how firm or soft your mattress should be. Side sleepers need the softest mattresses, while stomach sleepers need the firmest. Everyone else falls somewhere in the middle of the firmness scale.

Side Sleepers

Side sleepers need the softest beds for one key reason: pressure points. When you sleep on your side, your hip and shoulder joints get pressed into the bed by your body weight. A soft mattress that pushes back against these sensitive pressure points can lead to pain in the hips and shoulders.

That means a mattress for side sleepers that can compress under the hips and shoulders to cushion them and absorb pressure. Having zoned support or multiple layers of foam for cushioning can also offer pain relief to side sleepers.

However, making sure your mattress is sufficiently soft is the primary key to keeping you pain-free. Choose a mattress that’s a 3 to a 4 on the firmness scale.

Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers need the highest firmness level of any sleep style, with some benefiting from an extra-firm mattress instead of a standard firm bed. When you sleep on your stomach, it causes your pelvis to sink into the bed. An overly thick or soft foam layer will let your hips sink too far down. This overarches the spine and leads to lower back pain.

That means you need a firm mattress (7 or even 8 on the firmness scale). A firm mattress will keep the pelvis lifted onto the sleep surface, keeping the spine aligned. That means a pain-free night’s sleep.

Alternatively, stomach sleepers who want a softer mattress can place a pillow underneath their hips to prevent sinkage. But even then, we don’t recommend going below a medium-firm on the firmness scale when considering mattresses for stomach sleeping.

Back Sleepers

Back sleepers tend to do best with medium-firm mattresses (6 on the firmness scale). This is because back sleepers need a balance of cradling and support that slightly favors support. This combination of support and cushioning keeps you lifted onto the sleeping surface while maintaining sufficient contouring.

That means a medium-firm mattress will fill in the gap in your lumbar region to keep your spine aligned. This is vital in a mattress for back sleepers to wake up pain-free, as an overly firm mattress won’t follow the curve of your spine to keep your lower back from collapsing. And an overly soft mattress won’t keep you lifted onto the sleep surface.

Combination Sleepers

Combination sleepers like to change things up. They don’t prefer strongly prefer any sleep position and may choose any one of them. That means combo sleepers need a medium mattress (5 on the firmness scale).

A medium mattress for combination sleepers is versatile enough to accommodate any of the sleep positions as long as you don’t maintain it all the time. If you strongly prefer one position over the others and only wake up in an alternate one every once in a while, you’re not a combo sleeper.

Body Type

Your body type doesn’t have as much of an impact on your firmness needs as your sleep style, but it does affect your firmness needs to some extent. Mattresses are designed to support the average human weight range, which is 130 to 230 pounds in the bedding industry.

That means if you fall above or below this range, it may affect the firmness level you need. Always consider the firmness that fits your sleep style your “baseline firmness.” You can go up or down from there based on your body type.

Average-Weight Sleepers

Average-weight sleepers are between 130 and 230 pounds. These sleepers generally don’t have to worry about how their body weight impacts their sleep needs. They can just get the best mattress for their sleep style and let that be that.

Heavier Sleepers

Those over 230 pounds are considered heavy or plus-size sleepers. When you’re over 230 pounds, mattresses designed for your sleep style may not offer you enough lift to keep you from sinking down into them.

That means you’ll likely need to go up a firmness level to get sufficient support in a mattress for heavy people. An example would be a heavier back sleeper. Normally, back sleepers need medium-firm mattresses. However, plus-size back sleepers will likely need to go up to a firm mattress to get the support they need to keep their spines aligned.

Petite Sleepers

Petite sleepers are those under 130 pounds. They tend to have the opposite problem of heavier sleepers. When you’re under 130 pounds, your body weight may not compress the bed enough for you to get sufficient contouring. This can lead to a mattress that feels overly firm and exerts too much pressure on your body.

That means you’ll probably need to go down a firmness level if you’re a petite sleeper. For example, stomach sleepers normally need a firm mattress. But petite stomach sleepers will likely do better on a medium-firm. It will still keep the pelvis from sinking, but it will offer enough cushioning to prevent pain.

Couples’ Considerations

Couples can have a hard time selecting a mattress to share, especially if they have vastly different body types and sleep styles. For instance, two average-weight side sleepers can probably find a good compromise on firmness. However, a heavier stomach sleeper and a petite side sleeper probably can’t.

The good news is couples who want to share a bed can still do so even if they need different mattress firmness levels. They just need to use a split king size mattress. A split king allows you to put two separate twin XL mattresses in the same king size bed frame. That way, each partner can have the firmness level they need without having to sleep in separate beds.

However, split king mattresses can be expensive. Some sleepers may find a mattress for couples with a medium feel is a perfectly acceptable compromise.

Material and Construction

All mattress types come in a range of firmness levels. That means you can get whatever mattress type you want regardless of your firmness needs. So the factor that impacts your choice of material the most is your own personal preference.

Memory Foam

Memory foam is one of the most popular bedding materials on the modern-day mattress market, and there’s a reason. Memory foam is the most contouring of all the bedding materials. That means this special type of foam makes the most pressure-relieving mattress on the market!

Memory foam mattresses can follow the curve of your body in a way other foams cannot. This offers you total spinal alignment and amazing pressure relief. So if you can’t seem to find a bed that gives you the kind of cradling you want, a memory foam mattress might be for you.

Memory foam mattresses have two main problems. First off, because traditional memory foam has a slow response time, a mattress with several layers of foam may have issues with body impressions and lag time in regaining its shape after you move. This won’t be an issue for sleepers who don’t move around a lot at night. But if you’re an active sleeper, it could be a problem.

The other issue with memory foam is heat retention. Traditional memory foam was hot as a desert wind. However, more modern memory foam has all kinds of cooling technologies like gel or mineral infusions, cooling gel top layers, and open-cell construction.

Even with all these cooling features, memory foam mattresses are not as cool as spring mattresses or latex. So hot sleepers should keep that in mind when shopping for cooling memory foam mattresses.

Latex Foam

Natural latex foam is made from the sap of the rubber tree. Liquid sap is processed into two basic types of latex foam: Talalay and Dunlop. Dunlop latex is dense and durable. Talalay latex is springy and contouring. So it’s not uncommon to find a latex mattress with a Dunlop base layer and a Talalay top layer.

Latex mattresses are fantastic choices for hot sleepers and active sleepers. Where memory foam can be slow to respond, latex bounces right back. And where memory foam retains heat, latex naturally circulates cool air throughout. That makes latex the perfect alternative for those who want a foam mattress but need a bit of extra bounce and breathability.

Latex is also the only all-natural mattress foam you can get. Memory foam is polyurethane, meaning it’s made of petroleum products. So if you want an all-natural foam with only plant-based ingredients and other eco-friendly materials, an organic latex mattress is virtually your only option.

Latex foam isn’t without its faults, though. Because it wants to retain its shape more than memory foam, it isn’t as contouring. That means even a Talalay latex mattress is less pressure-relieving than memory foam. This isn’t a problem for everyone, but if you need the ultimate contouring to relieve issues like joint pain, you might be better off with memory foam.

Innerspring

Innerspring mattresses are made using open coil systems topped with a thinner top layer that can be made using a lot of different materials, such as foam, cotton, fiberfill, or wool.

The open coil system in a spring mattress is wired together from end to end. That makes innerspring mattresses the coolest and lightest of all the beds. However, their construction tends to create more problems than it solves.

For one thing, open coils tend to sag rather than contour because they’re all networked together. This can pull your spine out of alignment. Being wired together also means open coil systems have a problem with motion transfer. Rather than isolating your movements, a spring mattress tends to transfer them all over the bed.

For these reasons, we recommend you avoid traditional innerspring mattresses unless they have a thick pillow top to add sufficient contouring and pressure relief. Pillow top and Euro tops are an extra layer of padding sewn over the mattress’s comfort layer. A pillow top that’s at least several inches thick can help counter some of the issues inherent to spring mattresses.

Hybrid

If you can’t give up coils but don’t want to deal with the issues that come with innerspring mattresses, you should think about a hybrid mattress. Hybrids have both spring and foam construction. That means they boast a lot of the best features of both spring and foam beds!

A hybrid mattress consists of a support core made of pocketed coils and a comfort layer made of at least two inches of latex or memory foam. This means a hybrid mattress offers tons more pressure relief and spinal alignment than an innerspring because pocketed coils can move independently of one another.

The independent movement of pocketed coils means a hybrid mattress can adapt all the way through. That’s something even a memory foam mattress can’t do because of its high-density support core. So if you want the ultimate in pressure relief, a memory foam hybrid may be up your alley.

Those who want the ultimate cooling and responsiveness should consider a latex hybrid. The coil core of a hybrid mattress offers even more bounce and breathability than latex alone. And it does it all without motion transfer because the individually wrapped coils can bounce underneath you without spreading your motion all over the bed.

Hybrids offer you all the best features of both coil and foam mattresses. However, all this comfort doesn’t come cheap. Hybrids are more expensive than memory foam and innerspring beds and less durable than latex.

That makes them the most expensive mattress type throughout their lifetimes. This is their biggest drawback, and it can make finding a quality hybrid mattress very difficult for many shoppers.

Saving on Casper Mattress Alternatives

Everybody wants to save when buying a mattress. There are plenty of ways to do just that! For one thing, always shop for a mattress-in-a-box or online mattress if you want to get the best mattress for the best deal.

Mattress companies that depend on brick-and-mortar establishments often charge more because they have to cover overhead that mattress-in-a-boxes just don’t have. Think power bills, personnel, and other big expenses that come with a brick-and-mortar store.

Plus, mattresses in a box tend to closely overlap with mail order mattresses, offering all the benefits of home delivery. Just make sure your mattress seller offers at least a 10-year warranty and a 100-day trial period, as these are good indicators they’ve made a quality product.

Hitting the mattress sales is another way to snag an amazing deal on some of the best mattresses. Sales to watch out for include:

• Presidents Day mattress sales
• Memorial Day mattress sales
• July 4th mattress sales
• Labor Day mattress sales
• Columbus Day mattress sales

Black Friday mattress sales are another time to watch for amazing deals, though you can find comparable sales throughout the year.

The best mattresses under $1000 also have year-round, budget-friendly prices. They may not have all the bells and whistles, but their designs emphasize value with durable comfort and support.

Shoppers who want more can look at some of the best mattresses under $2000 if they want more special features without overspending.

SEE ALSO: Best Place to Buy a Mattress

FAQs

What’s the best Casper alternative for hot sleepers?

There are lots of fantastic alternatives to the Casper Mattress lineup if you’re a hot sleeper. Those looking for a foam mattress should check out the Amerisleep AS3 for its ultra-breathable plant-based memory foam. If you’re looking for a hybrid mattress, we’d have to give the edge to the GhostBed Flex for its multi-layered cooling system.

How do I know if my mattress is of good quality?

Two of the best ways to tell if a mattress is of sufficient quality are its trial period and limited warranty. Mattresses should offer at least a 100-day trial period and a 10-year warranty. A trial period and 10-year limited warranty are good minimums to indicate a mattress manufacturer believes in their products’ durability and knows you’ll be satisfied with them.

What is the best alternative to the Casper Wave Hybrid?

The best alternative to the Casper Wave Hybrid is the Zoma Hybrid. This hybrid mattress offers a similar firmness level and similar feel at a much better price. While a queen Casper Wave Hybrid is almost $3000, the Zoma Hybrid queen comes in at just under $1,000. Those are some massive savings for a similar feel.

Which firmness is best for back pain?

Generally, the best firmness level for back pain is medium-firm. A medium-firm mattress offers the best balance between support and comfort to support your back and still provide sufficient pressure relief. Of course, you should always take your sleep style and body type into account. However, if you have back pain, the general rule is the firmer the bed, the better.

What is the best alternative to the Casper Original Hybrid?

The best alternative to the Casper Original Hybrid is the Nolah Evolution 15. This mattress offers a similar firmness level, but it has more cooling technologies than the Casper Original Hybrid for a slightly lower price. That means if you want the best cooling tech in the industry, go with the Evolution.

Bottom Line

There are tons of amazing mattresses on the market that offer you pressure relief and support. If you want to get the best mattress for you, just keep your body type and sleep style in mind. And if you want to find the best deal, look for sales and stick to mattress-in-a-box stores.

Dr. Burns tests each mattress at eachnight’s facility to make sure the recommendations are based on real, expert reviews.